Should you outsource your marketing, hire someone or neither yet?

Outsourced marketing, an in-house hire or neither yet? Every kind of help assumes something about your problem. Here's how to pick the one that fits.

TL;DR

Decide what the problem is before you decide who to hire. Outsource when you know what needs doing and you need hands. Hire in-house when the work is permanent and someone can tell the new person what to do. Do neither yet when nobody can say in a sentence what's broken.

Every kind of help assumes something about your problem. An agency assumes you know what to make. A consultant assumes there's a question to answer. A fractional CMO assumes there's a function to run. An in-house hire assumes there's a plan to follow. Hire the one whose assumption is wrong and you pay a fair price for good work aimed at the wrong thing. Name the problem first and the choice mostly makes itself.

Related: Agency, consultant or fractional CMO? · What is a fractional CMO? · How much does a marketing consultant cost?

The short answer

Write one sentence before you call anyone: what's broken, and how you know.

If the sentence is about output, something like "we know what to say and nobody has time to make it", outsource it. An agency or a freelancer can start quickly, and you can stop when the work is done.

If the sentence is about work that will still need doing in three years, and someone in the business can direct it, hire. A person on the payroll learns the business in a way an outside firm rarely does.

If you can't finish the sentence, or three people in the business would finish it three different ways, do neither yet. Find out what's broken first. A hire made before that is a guess, and you pay for the guess every month.

What I think

Hiring is a capability answer to a clarity question.

Most owners I talk to have decided they need marketing help long before they've decided what the help is for. Of course they have. Hiring is the thing you can do this week. You can post a job, ask a friend for an agency's name or book three calls. Working out what's actually wrong is slower.

Capability only helps once you know where to point it. Every kind of help arrives with a guess about your problem built in. When the guess is right, the work goes well. When it's wrong, good people do good work on the wrong thing, and it looks like you hired badly.

I've worked inside an agency, and I've been the in-house marketing hire at a large company, so I've been on both sides of this decision. In both seats the work went best when the person buying it could say what it was for.

Before you hire execution, know what problem they're solving.

Eight months looking for a marketer

Oaceus sells Section 125 and 105 preventive health plans to employers. It's a real, IRS-compliant structure in a category crowded with companies whose claims don't hold up against the tax code. One wrong sentence in a sales email can create real exposure.

The CEO, Sabrina Delliquadri, put it this way: "I've been on a hunt for a good marketer for like eight months." She had already tried outsourcing. She'd let two outside firms go when nothing got put out.

What she asked me for was content. A battle card, some blog posts, an email sequence. None of it had shipped for a while, because every sales deck, blog post and internal email had to be read word for word by Sabrina, and then by outside counsel, before it could leave the building.

She wasn't being precious about it. In that category, she had to read everything. Between her and counsel sat the only judgment in the company that could say whether a sentence was safe to send.

So every obvious answer was a capability answer. A good marketer would have written faster and then waited in the same queue. Another firm would have hit the same wall. They also thought about hiring one more compliance person and decided against it, because one more person still reviews at the speed of one person.

The fix sat upstream of marketing. The judgment in those two heads had to be written down somewhere the rest of the company could reach it: what's true, what's sayable and what's never said. Once it was, anyone could draft something, check it against that and have a reviewable draft in minutes. Sabrina still reviews. She just doesn't have to do the writing.

Eight months was a reasonable search for a role that couldn't have fixed the problem.

The four kinds of help, and what each one assumes

Each of these is the right answer to some problem. The trouble starts when you hire one for a problem it assumes away. If you want them compared by fit, I've put an agency, a consultant and a fractional CMO side by side.

An agency assumes you know what to make. Agencies are built to produce: campaigns, content, ads, websites, at a pace and range one person can't match. Give one a clear brief and it will usually deliver it well. Give it a vague one and it will fill the gap with its own guess, aimed at a problem you haven't confirmed. With a clear brief, an agency is often the best answer on this list. How to hire a marketing agency, and what to tell it first.

A consultant assumes there's a question to answer. A good one tells you what to fix first and why, then either does it or hands it to whoever should. That's worth paying for when you can't say what's wrong. It's poor value when you already know and just need the work done. What a small business marketing consultant does, and what to look for if you sell to other businesses.

A fractional CMO assumes there's a function to run. A part-time head of marketing sets the plan, manages the people and the agencies and owns the numbers. If you have marketing people, a budget and nobody senior directing them, that's often exactly the right hire. If there's nobody to manage and no plan yet, you're paying someone to run a department that doesn't exist. What a fractional CMO does, and whether you need one.

An in-house hire assumes there's a plan to follow. A marketing manager on the payroll learns your business, your customers and your quirks in a way no outside firm will. That's the strongest option when the work is permanent and someone can tell them what to do. Without that, a good hire spends the first months working out which version of the company is the true one. Your first marketing hire, and what to hand them.

Match the assumption to your problem and any of the four can be the right call.

In-house or outsourced: the honest trade-offs

The choice depends less on price than on what kind of work it is.

In-house wins on context. Someone who's there every day hears the sales calls, knows which customers matter and picks up what changed last week without a meeting. The cost is commitment. You pay a salary and benefits whether the month is busy or quiet, the search can take months and you get one person's range of skills. When they leave, much of what they knew leaves with them unless someone wrote it down.

Outsourcing wins on range and flexibility. You get several skills at once, you can usually start in weeks and you can stop. The cost is distance. An outside firm knows your business only as well as you brief it, and it's splitting its attention across other clients. It needs someone on your side to direct it, approve the work and decide what counts as working.

Some firms sell an outsourced marketing department, strategy through to execution under one contract. That can work well. It carries an agency's assumptions and a fractional CMO's at the same time, so it needs the problem named as much as either of them does.

Both models fail the same way when nobody has said what's broken. In-house, it looks like a busy person producing work nobody can judge. Outsourced, it looks like monthly reports that read fine and results that don't move.

Pick in-house for context and permanence, outsourced for range and flexibility and neither for a problem you haven't named.

When the answer is neither yet

Sometimes the honest answer is to hire nobody this month.

That's true when you can't finish the sentence from the short answer, or when the people in the business finish it differently. It's also true when you've already tried one kind of help and got roughly what you got from the kind before. Oaceus had tried firms and was looking for a hire, and the answer was neither.

Not yet doesn't mean doing nothing. It means taking a short, cheap look at what's broken before you sign anything long. Ask a few recent customers why they chose you. Watch where people who've never heard of you drop out. Ask whoever sells for you what buyers keep asking that the marketing doesn't answer. If you've been spending and nothing's moving, start with why your marketing isn't working. If it turns out not enough people know you exist, sometimes you really do need more marketing.

Then hire, with the sentence written down to hand them.

What it costs

I've put consultant, agency, fractional CMO and in-house costs side by side, and the useful comparison is within the kind of help you've chosen, not across all four.

Where to go from here

If you're weighing a part-time head of marketing, start with what a fractional CMO does. If you're choosing between kinds of outside help, agency, consultant or fractional CMO compares them by the problem each one fits. If you can't yet say what's wrong, read what a small business marketing consultant does, or what to look for in a B2B marketing consultant if your buyers are other businesses. If you're ready to put someone on the payroll, your first marketing hire covers who it should be and what to hand them. And if you already know what you need made, how to hire a marketing agency starts with the brief.

Not sure which problem you're looking at? The Quick Read is free and takes three minutes. It tells you whether it's the look, the message or something else. Take the Quick Read

Read next: Your first marketing hire · Why isn't my marketing working? · Oaceus


Not sure which problem you’re looking at?

The Quick Read is free and takes three minutes. It tells you whether it’s the look, the message or something else.

Take the Quick Read

Already know? The Outside Read is one week and $1K.