What a small business marketing consultant does, and when to hire one

What a small business marketing consultant does in the first month, when one is worth it, when it isn't and how to tell a good one from a bad one.

TL;DR

A good small business marketing consultant tells you what to fix first and why, then either does it or hands it to the right person. That's the job. Most owners already have a list of ideas. What's hard is knowing which one matters now.

So a consultant is worth it when you can't say in a sentence what's wrong. Sales have stalled or the leads are the wrong ones. Maybe you've tried two kinds of help and got the same result from both. It isn't worth it when you already know what needs doing and just need someone to do it. Then you want hands, not a diagnosis, and an agency, a freelancer or a hire will serve you better.

The test before you pay anyone: can you name the problem? If you can't, that's the first job.

Related: Should you outsource your marketing, hire someone or neither yet? · Agency, consultant or fractional CMO? · Hiring a B2B marketing consultant

The short answer

What does a marketing consultant do? For a small business, three things, in order. They work out what's actually holding growth back. They tell you what to fix first and why it comes before everything else. Then they either do the work or hand it to whoever should, with a brief clear enough that the work lands on the right thing.

Most of the value is in the first two. The third is where most help starts, which is why so much good work ends up aimed at the wrong problem.

Should a small business bring one in? When the problem is unclear, yes. When the problem is clear and you just need it done, no. Spend the money on the doing.

What I think

A consultant's job is to put things in order.

Most owners I talk to aren't short of ideas. A new site is on the list, a newsletter, more posts, maybe ads, maybe a salesperson. Every item is reasonable. They can't all be first, though, and the thing that matters most is often missing from the list, because it's hard to see from inside the business.

That's not a failing. When you run the place, you see the symptom you can do something about this week. A consultant earns the fee by finding what sits behind it, and by telling you plainly what to leave alone for now.

So judge one by the end of the work, not the start. You should know what to do first, and why.

What a consultant does in the first month

The first month should be mostly listening and looking, then one clear piece of writing.

Listening means you first, and then your customers. Why did your best customers choose you? What almost stopped them? Their answers often differ from what your website says, and that gap is usually worth finding.

Looking means what a buyer actually sees. The site, the proposals, the ads, the emails a lead gets after they fill in a form. And whatever numbers you have, even rough ones: where inquiries come from, how many turn into calls, how many calls turn into work.

Then it gets written down. A good consultant ends that first stretch with three things on a page: the problem in a sentence, the first fix with the reason it comes first and who should do it. You should be able to hand that page to an agency, a freelancer or a new hire and have them understand it without a meeting.

If you're a month in with a long list of recommendations and no order, you've paid for ideas. You had those already.

Never a lack of demand

Peak Value is a business brokerage. The founder left a large international firm to start his own, which raised an obvious question for any owner thinking about selling: why choose him instead?

The answer was already in how he talked. Most of the category talks about the transaction: listings, valuation, multiples, closing. He talked about the owner. What someone who has spent decades building a company is walking away from, and whether the business is ready to be sold at all. We built the positioning around that idea and called it Exit Readiness.

Then the marketing worked. His calendar filled with owners who were interested but three, five, sometimes ten years away from selling.

From the outside, that looked like a healthy calendar. From the inside, the founder was spending call after call working out who was actually ready. The easy reading is that the leads were bad. They weren't. They were early. Throw them away and you pay to find them again later. Keep sorting them by hand and you've created another full-time job.

The case page puts it this way: "The problem was never a lack of demand. It was knowing which demand was ready."

So the next piece of work wasn't more leads. We took what he already knew about preparing a company for sale and turned it into a long-term content sequence, matched to where an owner was in the life of the business and in the decision to sell. What people opened, came back to and finished became a sign of how ready they were. The CRM kept that history, so by the time someone reached his calendar, he had a much better idea of who he was talking to and why. It changed the advertising too. Instead of paying for broad volume and sorting it by hand, the spend could go to a smaller, more relevant audience.

It's still early. Brokerage has a long sales cycle, and some of the people in that system are years from a sale. What it shows is the order. Answer a full calendar of unready owners with more leads and you fill it faster with the same problem.

That's what a consultant is for: naming the problem you actually have. The full Peak Value story.

Is it worth it for a small business?

It's the question people ask on Reddit. The honest answer is sometimes, and you can usually tell which time it is before you spend anything.

It's worth it when:

  • you can't say in a sentence what's wrong, only that growth has stalled
  • you've changed agencies, platforms or campaigns and got roughly the same result each time
  • the business has changed (a new market, a new service, the founder stepping back from selling) and the marketing still describes the old one
  • you're about to put real money into a site, a hire or a retainer and aren't sure it's aimed at the right thing

It isn't worth it when you already know what needs doing. If the site is broken and you know what it needs to say, pay someone to build it. If you need posts every week and you know what they should say, that's a freelancer or an agency, and they'll do it better and for less than a consultant will. If the work is permanent and someone can tell a new person what to do, make the hire.

It also isn't worth it yet if nobody will have time to act on what you learn. Wait until someone does.

One middle path is worth knowing about. You can pay for the diagnosis on its own, with no commitment to the work that follows. A good consultant will be comfortable with that, because a clear diagnosis is useful whoever does the work.

How to tell a good one from a bad one

Ask these before you sign anything.

What would you look at first, and why? A good answer is about your customers and your numbers. A weak one is a tour of their services.

When have you told a client they didn't need you? Anyone who has done this long enough has a story. If they can't think of one, they may be selling the same answer to everyone. I have one of my own: I should've said no to the job.

What will I have at the end of the first month? You want something written: the problem, the first fix, the reason and who does it.

Who does the work after that? They might do it themselves, bring in specialists or hand it to your own people. Any of those can be right. What matters is that they're clear about it before you start.

What would change your mind? A good consultant arrives with a view and holds it loosely. Ask what evidence would make them drop it.

The red flags mirror those questions. A plan before any questions. The same channel offered as the answer to every problem. A six-month retainer before anyone has said what's wrong. Nothing in writing.

I've been on the other side of these conversations, inside an agency and in-house. The people worth hiring asked more than they pitched.

What it costs

It depends on the kind of help and how it's priced, so I've put consultant, agency, fractional CMO and in-house costs side by side.

Where to start

Before you call anyone, write down what you think the problem is, in one sentence. If you can do that with confidence, you may not need a consultant. Hand the sentence to whoever will do the work. If you can't, that's the job a consultant is for.

If you'd like to talk about whether I'm the right person for yours, here's how working with me starts.

Not sure which problem you're looking at? The Quick Read is free and takes three minutes. It tells you whether it's the look, the message or something else. Take the Quick Read

Read next: A calendar full of people who weren't ready · What is a fractional CMO, and do you need one? · How much does a marketing consultant cost?


Not sure which problem you’re looking at?

The Quick Read is free and takes three minutes. It tells you whether it’s the look, the message or something else.

Take the Quick Read

Already know? The Outside Read is one week and $1K.