Agency, consultant or fractional CMO? Which one fits your problem
Agency, consultant or fractional CMO? Each one assumes something about your problem. How to tell which fits before you hire, and when it's none of them.
TL;DR
Pick the kind of help by what you don't know yet. If you can't say what's wrong, you need someone to find it, and that's a consultant's job. If you know exactly what needs making, an agency will make it well. If you know what to do but nobody senior is running it, that's what a fractional CMO is for.
Each one is good at its own job, and each one starts from an assumption about your problem. Hire the one whose assumption is wrong and you pay a fair price for good work aimed at the wrong thing. That's why so many owners switch providers and get the same result.
So before you compare names or prices, write the problem down in one sentence. The sentence usually tells you which kind of help to call.
Related: Should you outsource your marketing, hire someone or neither yet? · What a small business marketing consultant does · Your first marketing hire
The short answer
Match the help to what you don't know yet.
| What you don't know yet | Who fits | What they'll assume |
|---|---|---|
| What's actually wrong | A consultant | That the answer isn't obvious yet, and you'll act on it once it is |
| Who'll make it | An agency | That you already know what to make and who it's for |
| Who'll run it week to week | A fractional CMO | That there's a function to run: a plan, a budget and people or vendors to manage |
If you can't tell which row you're in, you're probably in the first one.
What I think
An agency can only solve the problem you point them at. I say that as someone who has worked inside one. A good agency takes a brief and makes it real, often better than you pictured it. What it can't do is tell you whether the brief was right. That was never its job, and the good ones will say so if you ask.
The same is true of the other two. A fractional CMO is hired to run marketing, and running something assumes you know what it's for. A consultant is hired to find the problem, and if you already know the problem, you're paying someone to repeat it back to you.
So the expensive mistake usually isn't picking a bad provider. It's picking a good one for the wrong job. That's how "we tried an agency and it didn't work" turns into "we tried another one and that didn't work either."
Most owners start with execution, and that makes sense. You can see the posts that aren't landing and the site that isn't producing. Hiring someone to make better ones is something you can do this week, and it feels like progress. Sometimes it is the right call. It depends on whether you already know what "better" means.
Same hooks, two ways
HindSight VIP makes blockchain data software. It had been selling to consumer crypto traders and was moving toward enterprise buyers: the people who run compliance, treasury, operations and risk.
On our first call, before we'd agreed to anything, the founder told me what they'd already tried. "We were paying marketers to do it, and we didn't like their hooks. We didn't think that was good content. We didn't continue using them, and then when we tried to do it ourselves, we were still like, these aren't great hooks. This isn't driving me to even click."
That's two kinds of help, one from outside and one from inside, with the same result. The marketers wrote weak hooks. The founders wrote weak hooks. When different people doing the same job keep getting the same result, the people usually aren't the problem.
The problem was what the company was saying and who it was saying it to. Language that worked on traders read as lightweight to a compliance officer or a treasurer. No hook writer could fix that, because every hook was being written in the old buyer's language for a new buyer. A better agency would have written better trader hooks. Doing it themselves got them the same hooks for more of their own time.
What the company needed first was a decision: who it was for now, and what it had to say so those people took it seriously. Once that was settled, anyone making posts had something to aim at. The repositioning held. The full case is here.
How to choose between an agency and a consultant
The test is whether you can write the brief. Try it now, on one page. Who it's for. What you want them to think or do. What you'll say to get them there. How you'll know it worked.
If you can fill that page and you believe it, hire an agency, or a freelancer if the job is small. You'll get more for your money, because you're paying for making, and making is what they do best. Here's how to hire one and what to tell it first.
If you stall on the second or third line, that's the part a consultant is for. It costs less to settle it before you hire people to make things than to pay them to discover it on your budget.
A freelance marketer sits on the agency side of this line, not the consultant side. They're hired to make things, usually in one specialty. The difference from an agency is size and range, not the job.
Where a fractional CMO fits
A fractional CMO is the right call when the pieces exist and nobody senior is running them. You have a direction you trust, some budget, a person or two and maybe an agency, and no one who owns the plan and the numbers. That's a real gap, and a good fractional CMO fills it well, for less than a full-time hire.
It's the wrong call when there's nothing yet to run. If there's no one to manage and no plan to follow, a fractional CMO either spends their hours making things or spends the first months working out what's wrong. Both are jobs you could have hired for more directly. More on what a fractional CMO does, and when you need one.
Signs you've picked the wrong kind
- You've changed agencies or freelancers and the results look about the same.
- The work is good, and you still can't say why it isn't working.
- Your provider keeps asking what you want, and your answer keeps changing.
- Every meeting is about the output (posts, pages, ads) and none is about the buyer.
- Your fractional CMO is spending most of their hours making things, not running anything.
- Your consultant handed you a report that told you what you already knew.
Each of these means the help and the problem don't match. None of them means the help is bad. If it's the first or second sign, this is where I'd start.
Can one person do all three?
Sometimes. You should know where I sit before you hear my answer. I'm a consultant. I find the problem, and on some projects I stay on and do the work that follows with specialists I bring in for that job. So I have a stake in this.
Here's the honest version. One person can find the problem and fix some of it. But finding and making are different skills, and being good at one doesn't make someone good at the other. The bigger risk is the incentive. Anyone who also sells the fix has a reason to find a problem that needs a lot of fixing.
There's a simple way to check. Ask anyone you're considering what they'd tell you if the answer were "you don't need me yet." Someone you can trust has said that to a client and can tell you when. I've written about a time I should have said it sooner.
Running the function is a different thing again. A fractional CMO is there every week for months, managing people and owning numbers. A consultant usually isn't. If you need marketing run, hire for that, and pick someone who'll tell you if the plan they inherit is wrong.
What it costs
I've put consultant, agency, fractional CMO and in-house costs side by side, so pick the kind of help first and compare prices within it.
What to do first
Write the problem down in one sentence before you call anyone. Not the solution, like "we need more content." The problem, like "the buyers we want now don't take us seriously" or "leads come in and go cold."
Then go back to the table at the top. If the sentence came easily, you probably know which row you're in. If it didn't, that's your answer. You need the problem found before you need it made or managed.
Not sure which problem you're looking at? The Quick Read is free and takes three minutes. It tells you whether it's the look, the message or something else. Take the Quick Read
Read next: What is a fractional CMO, and do you need one? · How to hire a marketing agency, and what to tell it first · How much does a marketing consultant cost?