How to hire a marketing agency, and what to tell it first

Hire an agency when you can hand it a clear brief. How to write that brief first, what to ask an agency and what to agree before you sign a retainer.

TL;DR

Hire an agency when you can hand it a clear brief: who you want to reach, what you want them to understand about you and what should change if it works. Then choose on fit to that brief, not on the portfolio, and agree what "working" means before you sign.

Most agencies are good at making things. What they aren't hired to do is decide what your business should be saying. Give a good agency a vague brief and it will do good work on the vague brief. The results tend to be mild, and mild results are easy to keep paying for.

So write the brief first. If you can't write it yet, an agency probably isn't your next call.

Related: Should you outsource your marketing, hire someone or neither yet? · Agency, consultant or fractional CMO? · What is a fractional CMO, and do you need one?

The short answer

Hire an agency when you can hand it a clear brief. Then pick on fit to that brief, not on portfolio, and agree what "working" means before you sign. Whether it's a digital marketing agency, a social media shop or a full-service firm, the order is the same: brief, then search, then terms.

If you can't write the brief, the first job is working out what the problem is. That's a different kind of help, and I've matched the kinds of help to the kinds of problem here.

What I think

An agency can only solve the problem you point it at.

I've worked inside an agency, so I mean that as a description of the job. The client brings a brief. The agency's work is to answer it well, with the right people, a sensible plan and good craft, on time. A good agency will push back on a brief that's plainly wrong. It's rarely paid to question one that's merely vague, and from the inside a vague brief often looks fine. "More presence on social" is something you can deliver.

That's why the quality of what you get back is capped by the quality of what you hand over.

Of course hiring looks like the answer. It's the thing you can do this week, and an agency gives you range you couldn't hire one person for: writing, design, video, ads and someone keeping it all on schedule. When you know what needs making and you need people who can make it well and steadily, an agency is the right call. The rest of this page is about doing it well.

Write the brief before the search. Then the search gets easier.

Social media that went fine

Grand Union is a Portland real estate firm. When they came to me, they wanted more presence on social media. That's an agency-shaped brief, and I didn't turn it down. I ran it the way a good agency would: new listings posted well, walkthroughs, neighborhood shots that looked like the neighborhood and accurate market notes. As I wrote afterwards, "None of it was lazy work and none of it was wrong."

The results were mild. Some posts did nothing, most did a little and a couple did better for reasons that never repeated. "That is what mild results do. They fund their own continuation." Nobody had a reason to stop, so the work kept going.

The check we weren't running was simple. Cover the name on a post, put a competitor's logo on it and ask whether anything looks wrong. Every post passed. The content was fine, and none of it belonged to Grand Union. Any firm in town could have posted it.

Look at it from Grand Union's side of the table. The brief asked for presence and it got presence. What it never asked was the question that should have come before anyone made anything: is this ours? What can this firm say that the firm down the street can't? Without an answer, nobody making the content, me or an agency, had anything of theirs to make it from.

The next thing they did was stop making content. I wrote up the full story here.

The work answered the brief. The brief never asked the question.

What to write before you call anyone

One page, five lines. Write it before the first call, and send it to every agency you talk to.

  1. Who you want to reach. Not "homeowners" or "manufacturers" but which ones, and what they're deciding when they find you.
  2. What you want them to understand about you. One sentence they don't believe yet and should.
  3. Why they'd pick you over the obvious alternative. If you can, ask three recent customers and use their words.
  4. What you need made. The kind of work and roughly how much of it.
  5. What should change if it works. The one thing you'd actually check: more calls from the right kind of buyer, fewer quotes to people who were never going to buy, a shorter first conversation.

Then run the swap on lines two and three. Put a competitor's name at the top. If they could sign it too, it isn't finished.

Lines four and five are the ones an agency can help you sharpen. Lines two and three are yours. If you can't write them, that's the sign the problem isn't execution yet, and this is where I'd start instead.

An agency can make the work. It can't supply the second line.

Questions to ask a marketing agency

These are the questions I'd ask any marketing partner, agency or not, and what to listen for.

  • "What would you change about this brief?" A good one finds something. Listen for whether they question who it's for and why, or only the list of deliverables.
  • "Who will do the work, and who will I talk to each week?" The people in the pitch aren't always the people on the account. Meet the ones who will be.
  • "Show me work for a client like us, and tell me what it was meant to change." A result without the brief behind it tells you very little.
  • "How will we both know at ninety days whether it's working?" If the answer is only reach and engagement, ask what those should lead to.
  • "What do you need from us, and how fast?" Approvals, access and someone who can answer questions. A lot of agency work stalls on the client's side, and a good agency will tell you so.
  • "What happens if it isn't working by month three?" You want a plan, not reassurance.
  • "If we part ways, what do we keep?" Files, logins, ad accounts and data.

The first question tells you the most. An agency that improves your brief before it's paid is showing you how it will work once it is.

Signs of a good one, and red flags

Most agencies I've known show the good signs. The red flags are still worth knowing, because a strong pitch can cover them.

Signs of a good one:

  • They ask about your customers before they talk about channels.
  • They push back on part of your brief, and they're specific about which part.
  • They tell you what they don't do.
  • Their references can say what changed, not only that they were good to work with.
  • They suggest a measure you can check yourself, without their report.

Red flags:

  • A plan or a proposal before anyone has asked who you sell to.
  • Guaranteed rankings, followers or leads.
  • Reports that stop at reach and impressions.
  • Senior people who are in the pitch and gone after the signature.
  • A long commitment with no point at which you can review it.
  • Your ad accounts, analytics or domain held in their name.

A good agency is easy to measure. A weak one is easier to keep.

What to agree before a six-month retainer

Most of what goes wrong on a retainer was left unsaid at the start. Agree these in writing before you sign.

What "working" means. One or two measures, taken from line five of your brief, in your buyers' terms. Reach can be a sign of progress. It shouldn't be the goal.

A review at month three. A fixed date when you look at the measures together and decide to carry on, change direction or stop. This is the point where mild results get a decision instead of another month.

What's in scope. What the fee covers, what counts as extra and how extras get approved.

Who owns what. Accounts, files, content and data are yours from day one, whoever set them up.

Who approves, and how fast. Name the person on your side. If approvals take two weeks, the agency can't move faster than that.

How it ends. The notice either side has to give and what gets handed over.

None of this is about distrust. It's what lets a good agency do good work without guessing what you'll judge it on.

What it costs

Agency fees depend on scope, model and who's doing the work, and I've put agency, consultant, fractional CMO and in-house costs side by side.

Before you start the search

Write the one page. If lines two and three come easily, you're ready for an agency, and the right one will make the page better in the first meeting. If they don't, find out what the problem is before you pay someone to make content about it.

Brief first. Then hire.

Not sure which problem you're looking at? The Quick Read is free and takes three minutes. It tells you whether it's the look, the message or something else. Take the Quick Read

Read next: We did the social media. It went fine, which was the problem. · Agency, consultant or fractional CMO? Which one fits your problem · How much does a marketing consultant cost?


Not sure which problem you’re looking at?

The Quick Read is free and takes three minutes. It tells you whether it’s the look, the message or something else.

Take the Quick Read

Already know? The Outside Read is one week and $1K.