Why isn't my marketing working?

Most marketing that "isn't working" is doing its job. The trouble is what it's carrying. How to tell which part is broken before you spend more on it.

TL;DR

Most of the time, the marketing is doing its job. It's getting your business in front of people. What isn't working is what those people find when they get there: they can't tell what you do, whether it's for them, or what to do next. So they leave, and it looks like the ads, the posts or the agency failed.

That's why changing the channel rarely fixes it. A new channel delivers more people to the same problem.

What I think

When an owner tells me their marketing isn't working, they usually mean one of two things. Either not enough people are showing up, or people are showing up and not buying. Those are different problems with different fixes, and most of the money gets wasted by treating the second one like the first.

More reach is the obvious fix, and it's what most help is set up to sell. It only works if the people you already reach would buy if there were more of them. If they're not buying now, more of them won't change that. Sometimes more reach really is the answer. Here's how to tell when it is.

So the first question isn't "what should we try next?" It's "where are people dropping out?"

Signs it isn't the channel

  • You're getting traffic, clicks or followers, and sales haven't moved.
  • People who call or meet you buy fairly often, but people who only see the website don't.
  • Your best salesperson explains the business differently from how the website does.
  • You've switched agencies, platforms or campaigns, and every one got roughly the same result.
  • When you ask customers why they chose you, the reason isn't anywhere in your marketing.

Any one of these points at the message, the page or the offer, not the channel.

How to tell which part is broken

Follow one stranger through it. Pick someone who's never heard of you and fits the customer you want. Watch what they'd see, in order: the ad or post, the page it leads to, the next step it asks for.

At each step, ask one question: would this person know what to do now, and want to?

Where the answer turns to no is where your marketing stops working. Fix that step first. Everything before it is paying to send people there.

I learned this the expensive way, with a CBD company I still work with. For ten months I ran their social. We got reach, and sales barely moved. Later we did search work, and Google went from showing their site about 14,000 times a month to 43,000. Clicks went from 188 to 241.

When someone searched for the company by name, more than half clicked through. When a stranger searched for a product, almost nobody did. One of their tinctures was shown in Google more than 15,000 times and got no clicks, because Google was showing people a blog post when they wanted to buy a bottle.

The strangers who did come through landed on dozens of products with names that only meant something if you already knew them. To buy, a newcomer had to work out what each product was, how strong it was, whether it had THC in it, and whether a capsule, a tincture or a gummy fit their life. In person, the owners answer every one of those questions in a sentence. On the site, the newcomer was on their own.

Every step before the website was doing its job. The website was where people dropped out, and for ten months, then seven more, we paid to send people there.

So the next thing I recommended wasn't more reach. It was fixing the pages strangers were already seeing, and tracking sales for the first time. If those pages showed no improvement by week eight, we would stop.

The full story, and what I'd do differently.

Why your ads aren't performing

Usually the ad is fine and the page behind it isn't. The platform will keep finding people who click. If the page doesn't tell them quickly what you do and who it's for, they bounce, and the cost per lead goes up. Before you change the targeting or the budget, look at the page.

Why you get visits but no sales

The site is built for people who already know you. Your regular customers know what your product names mean and which page to go to. A stranger doesn't. If the site only makes sense to people who already know you, it can't turn strangers into customers, however many you send. That was the CBD company's problem. A full answer on websites is coming.

Sometimes it was never working

Some businesses sell well for years because the founder or a senior person does the explaining in the room. When someone new starts selling, or the business starts relying on the website, the explaining stops and sales drop. It looks like marketing stopped working. It was never doing that job. More on that here.

How much should I spend on marketing?

There's no right number until you know what's broken. If people drop out at your website, a bigger budget makes the problem more expensive. The five things I'd want to know before setting one.

If you're weighing what different kinds of help cost, I've put consultant, agency, fractional CMO and in-house costs side by side.

What to do first

Name the problem before you pay for a fix. Write down, in a sentence, where people are dropping out and why you think so. If you can, have someone who isn't selling you the fix check it.

If you'd like a second pair of eyes on yours, book a 15-minute call. I'll tell you where I think people are dropping out, and whether it's something I'd help with.

Read next: I should've said no to the job · The messaging was never working · How much does a marketing consultant cost?


Not sure which problem you’re looking at?

The Quick Read is free and takes three minutes. It tells you whether it’s the look, the message or something else.

Take the Quick Read

Already know? The Outside Read is one week and $1K.