I wouldn't spend another dollar until I knew these five things.
How much should a small business spend on marketing? It depends on five facts most owners can't state yet. Here's a company that found out first.
TL;DR
A marketing budget is supposed to answer a simple question: how much should the business spend to grow? Fair enough. Except the number depends on a few things most owners can't say with much confidence. Where the last few customers came from. What happens when someone makes an inquiry. What a stranger finds on the website. Whether there is a single client result anyone can point to. And whether people are buying from the company or buying because they trust the person running it.
Without those answers, a marketing budget is mostly a guess with a dollar sign in front of it. And the problem with guessing isn't always that the business spends too much. It's that it spends on the wrong thing. Sometimes more marketing is exactly what a company needs. But spending more on something that isn't working doesn't make it work. It just makes the mistake more expensive.
The $156K never showed up as a budget line. It lived inside the company's own calendar. It's hard to read the label from inside the bottle.
<iframe src="https://www.youtube.com/embed/tbaYDEGNtII" width="560" height="315"></iframe>
The Outside Read is one week with someone who isn't inside it, and one clear answer about what's stuck. Book the Outside Read
The request
A regulated health-benefits company came in asking for a battle card, some blog posts and an email sequence.
Reasonable request. The sales team needed something to hand prospects. The website needed more to say. People who had already shown interest needed a reason to keep listening. Nothing about it was unusual.
It's hard to argue with that until the question changes from what the company needs to produce to why it hasn't produced it already. Those are two different problems.
What was actually happening
The company wasn't short on people who could write. It was short on things that could get approved.
Every sales deck, every blog post and every internal email had to be read line by line by the CEO. Outside counsel read them too. This wasn't a controlling executive who couldn't let other people touch the work. It was a regulated business. A wrong sentence could create real exposure, and somebody had to make sure the company wasn't saying something it shouldn't.
Perfectly reasonable. Except that everything waited for those two people, and both had other jobs. The writing could be finished. The sales team could need it. The company could have every reason to publish it. Until the CEO and counsel had read it, it wasn't going anywhere.
When the cost of all that reading was added up, it came to $156K a year. Four hours a week of the CEO's time and outside counsel's time, spent reviewing marketing. That expense had never appeared as a budget line. Nobody had approved it as a marketing investment. Yet it was the single largest marketing expense the company had.
The company thought it needed to spend more money producing content. Meanwhile it was already spending $156K a year trying to get content out the door. Another writer wouldn't solve that. More blog posts wouldn't solve it. A bigger budget would have put more work into the same queue.
The proposed solution wasn't going to remove the problem. It was going to feed it.

Do the Quick Read. It's free, and it shows where your business fits. Take the Quick Read
The honest case for spending
There's a legitimate objection to all this. Some businesses really do need more marketing.
Not every slow pipeline is hiding a deeper organizational issue. Sometimes a business has a strong offer, knows exactly who buys it, does good work, follows up properly and simply isn't getting in front of enough people. There's no mystery to solve there. Being good at the work and being known for the work are not the same thing. And there is a cost to being overly cautious. A business that's ready to grow can spend so much time diagnosing itself that it misses the opportunity sitting in front of it.
For that company, more spending makes sense. The investment has something productive to work with.
But that wasn't this company. The difference shows up before the money gets spent.
In a business that's ready for more attention, inquiries arrive and get answered the same day. Someone encountering the website for the first time can find at least one real result. The owner knows where the last three customers came from without digging through a CRM. The business has a way to turn attention into a conversation, and a conversation into a customer. It just needs more people entering that process.
This company had almost none of those signs. Its inquiries waited. Its website said as little as compliance would allow. Its best evidence was sitting in drafts that hadn't been cleared. The company couldn't publish what it already had.
What I'd want to know first
When somebody asks how much a business should spend on marketing, the first question isn't really about money. It's about what the business already knows. There are five things I'd want to understand before recommending another dollar. Not because every company needs an elaborate investigation, but because these are the facts that separate a business that needs more attention from one that's losing the attention it already gets.
The first is where recent customers actually came from. Not the source field in the CRM. The actual reason somebody showed up, in the customer's own words. That distinction gets lost easily. A customer might appear as a website inquiry when the reason they visited the website was that somebody they trusted recommended the company. The website was where they made contact. It wasn't necessarily what brought them there. A business growing through a handful of trusted relationships has a different job from one growing through search. Both can be healthy. But spending money as if they're the same business is a good way to get an expensive result that doesn't tell much, and a lot of owners aren't as clear on which one they are as they think.
Then there's what happens after an inquiry arrives. Marketing gets credit for bringing people in. Sales gets credit for closing them. The space between those two events can become everybody's responsibility and nobody's job. Who answers, how quickly, what happens next, and whether that next step actually happens. If a company already has inquiries going unanswered, buying more inquiries is a strange place to start.
The third is what somebody who has never heard of the company can actually find. Not what the team knows about itself. Not what the founder believes makes the company special. What is there, on the website, in the first thirty seconds. This gets particularly hard in a regulated business. Every claim carries some risk. Every promise has to be defensible. So language gets reviewed, softened, qualified and sometimes removed altogether. The reasons are legitimate, but after enough of that the company can end up saying almost nothing. It has reduced its exposure, and in the process made itself much harder to choose. That's a different problem from needing more traffic.
Fourth is whether the business has a result it can actually show. Just one. A real client, a real change, described plainly enough that somebody outside the company can understand what happened and check the claim. It doesn't need to be spectacular. It needs to be something the company can stand behind. Without it, marketing leans on claims about quality, service and expertise, which are hard enough to make distinctive and, in a regulated business, exactly the kind of claims that slow approval down.
And finally, who the customer is really choosing. The company, or the person who runs it? Plenty of successful firms have grown because the founder has relationships, credibility and a reputation people trust. Often that's the most valuable thing the business has. But when people are buying because of the founder, marketing has a different job. It has to help somebody develop confidence in the business without that person in the room. More attention won't create that on its own.
In this company, nobody had looked into most of them. Not because the people were careless, but because the same approval queue that held up the marketing was consuming the time needed to understand why it wasn't working. The person with the most authority to move things forward had become the narrowest point in the process.
Why nobody could see it
The original request wasn't wrong. The pipeline was thin. The website didn't say much. The sales team needed better material. All true. The mistake was deciding that those observations explained the problem.
From inside the business, the approval process didn't look like a bottleneck. It looked like diligence. In a regulated company, diligence is a virtue. The CEO was reading every line because the consequences of getting something wrong were real. Nobody was going to criticize that, least of all the CEO. So the company treated the delay as part of doing business responsibly, rather than asking whether the responsibility had to be handled that way.
There was another reason it stayed hidden. The expense wasn't on an invoice. It sat in calendars rather than the marketing budget, so finance never flagged it and the board never asked.
What it costs, besides money
The $156K was the expense nobody had counted, and the money was only part of it. Four hours a week of the most important person in the company, spent reading marketing drafts instead of running the business. That's time not spent with major accounts, not spent hiring, not spent deciding where the company goes next. And unlike a vendor invoice, it never arrives with an explanation of what the company got in return.
That's how a business can spend real money on marketing, have capable people doing the work, and still have very little to show for it. The visible problem is a lack of output. The expense is all the effort required to produce so little of it.
What it turned into
The answer wasn't to stop being careful. This was still a regulated company. Outside counsel still mattered. The CEO still needed authority over what the business said.
The change was deciding what could and couldn't be said in advance, so approved language could be used without every new piece going through the same review. The CEO still had the final word. It just didn't have to be exercised on every draft.
And the things required to make that possible were largely things the business already had. The offer was sound. The buyers were real. The team knew how to write. The company didn't need to reinvent its business or replace its people. It needed to stop treating the absence of published content as proof that it needed to buy more content, because the thing holding it back was happening after the writing was finished.
So how much should a small business spend?
There isn't a responsible number without knowing what the money is supposed to fix.
Sometimes the answer really is more. A business with a clear offer, proof that customers value it and a working way to turn inquiries into sales may be losing opportunities simply because too few people know it exists. In that situation, holding back is its own expensive mistake.
There's an incentive problem worth naming, too. A free marketing audit almost always finds something to sell. That's not necessarily because the advice is dishonest. It's because the person doing the audit is usually in the business of selling what comes next. A diagnosis that can't end with "not yet" isn't much of a diagnosis.
This business came looking to spend money on marketing. What it already had was a sound offer, real buyers, people who could do the work, and a $156K expense hiding inside an approval process. The answer wasn't a bigger budget. It was finding out where the existing money and time were going. Once that was clear, the next dollar finally had somewhere sensible to go.
Want a read on your own business? The Outside Read is one week and one clear answer about what's actually stuck. Book the Outside Read
Read next: Grand Union, reviewed before any more marketing · How much does a marketing consultant cost? · I should've said no to the job