Your first marketing hire: who it should be, and what to hand them
Before your first marketing hire, write down who you sell to, why they buy and what ninety days should produce. Then pick the right title and hand it over.
TL;DR
Hire a marketing person when someone can tell them what to do. Before the first hire, write down who you sell to, why they buy from you and what the first ninety days should produce. That page is what a good hire needs on day one, and most small firms don't have it.
Without it, the hire's first job becomes working out what the company is. A good one will try. They'll talk to the founder, the salespeople and a few customers, and they'll hear a different version from each. Months go to that before any of the work you hired them for.
The hire inherits whatever clarity you have. So settle the story, write it down, then hire someone to run it. When the plan exists and the work is permanent, a hire is often the right call.
Related: Should you outsource your marketing, hire someone or neither yet? · Agency, consultant or fractional CMO? Which one fits your problem · How to hire a marketing agency, and what to tell it first
The short answer
Hire a doer only when someone can tell them what to do. If you're about to hire a marketing person for a small business, the first one should usually be a capable generalist who can run a plan, not a senior leader you expect to invent one.
Before you post the job, write down three things: who you sell to, why they buy and what the first ninety days should produce. If you can't write those yet, settle them first and hire second. Without them, a good hire can spend a year guessing.
What I think
Of course hiring looks like the answer. Marketing feels behind, you've been doing it yourself at night and a hire is something you can start this week. At least it becomes someone's job.
But the hire inherits whatever clarity you have. If you know who you sell to and why they choose you, a good marketer turns that into a plan and runs it. If you don't, they inherit the question, and they're the person least placed to answer it. They're new. They don't know your customers. They weren't in the room when the business won its best work. The answer lives in your head and in your salespeople's heads, usually in slightly different versions.
Hiring is a capability answer to a clarity question. If the problem is that nobody has time to do the marketing, a hire fixes it. If the problem is that nobody can say what the marketing should say, a hire walks straight into it.
I know because I've been that hire.
Four divisions, four versions
I worked in-house at Viasat, on the brand and content team. This was a job, not a client. Viasat had four businesses: defense, commercial aviation, enterprise broadband and telecom. Each had its own buyer and its own way of describing the company.
When I joined, nobody could hand me one version of the company. Each division had its own, and each made sense from where that division sat. Inside, the same wording got debated again and again. Investor research found the same gap from the outside: analysts understood the segments they covered but not how the whole company fit together.
It took me about a year to work out which story was true, before I could do much of the actual job. That's where a new hire's time goes when there's no single version to start from. The company later built one structure for its story with the divisions, and that's on the case page.
Viasat is a large company with four divisions. A 20-person firm has the same problem on a smaller scale. The founder tells it one way, the best salesperson another and the website a third. A new marketer walks into that and has to pick one, or write a fourth.
Manager, director or head of marketing?
Pick the title by what the person will be asked to decide.
A marketing manager runs a plan. They write, publish, keep the calendar, look after the email list and the events, manage a freelancer or two and report what happened. They're the right first hire when the plan already exists.
A marketing director sets the plan and owns the results. They decide where the money goes, manage the people and agencies doing the work and answer to you for the numbers. They're the right hire when there's a function to run: a budget to spend, channels that already bring in leads and people or vendors to manage.
A head of marketing or VP sits at the leadership table and shapes what the company sells and to whom, not only how it's promoted. Most firms under 50 people don't need that as a full-time seat yet.
The common mistake is hiring a manager and expecting a director's decisions. The manager does what managers do, which is make things. Without a plan, they make whatever's asked for this week. The opposite mistake is hiring a director to work out the story from scratch. They'll get further, but they still need answers only you and your customers have.
If you're not sure there's a function to run yet, a part-time senior person can bridge the gap. Here's when a fractional CMO makes sense.
A manager needs a plan. A director needs a function.
What to hand them on day one
Here's the list I'd have wanted. None of it has to be polished. It has to be written down, and it has to be one version.
- Who you sell to. The two or three kinds of buyer who bring in most of your best work, described the way you'd describe them to a friend.
- Why they buy from you. In your customers' words. Ask a handful of recent customers why they chose you and write down what they say. If it doesn't match your website, give the hire both and say which is true.
- One version of what you are. A paragraph the founder, the salespeople and the website would all agree with. If you can't get them to agree, that's the first problem to settle, and it shouldn't be the new hire's job.
- What the first ninety days should produce. Something you could check at the end, like a rewritten proposal template, a follow-up sequence that runs or the three case studies you keep meaning to write. "More leads" isn't a brief.
- What's been tried. Past agencies, campaigns and what happened. A hire who doesn't know what failed will try it again.
- Who decides. Who signs off on what, how fast and what needs your eyes. A lot of marketing stalls quietly in approval.
- The proof they can use. Which clients can be named, which numbers are real and which stories need permission first.
- Access. Logins for the site, the email tool, the CRM and analytics, on day one rather than week three.
That page is worth writing even if you never hire. What you write down stays when the hire leaves. What they work out in their head goes with them.
When a hire beats outsourcing
Sometimes hiring is plainly the right call, and outside help would be the weaker choice.
A hire wins when the work is permanent. If you need someone writing, publishing, following up and running events every week for years, a person inside the business will usually do it better than someone outside it. They hear the sales calls. They know which customer just had a rough month. They're around when the founder has an idea.
A hire wins when the plan exists. If you can hand over the list above, a capable generalist can start producing in the first month instead of the fourth.
And a hire wins when the knowledge compounds. Every month inside, they learn your buyers better. That learning stays in the business, as long as someone writes it down. It's also how an in-house marketing team starts: one good person with a clear plan, then a second when the first is stretched.
I've worked on both sides of this, inside a company and outside it. For steady work with a clear plan, inside usually wins.
When the work is permanent and the plan is written, hire.
When it doesn't
A hire is the wrong first move in a few situations.
When nobody can say what's broken. If sales have flattened and nobody can say why in a sentence, the hire inherits the question. Settle that first, then hire someone to run the answer. Here's where I'd start looking.
When the work has an end. A new website, a launch, a rename. Hire for the project, not the year. When the project ends, a full-time hire is left looking for something to do.
When you want one person to be everything. Strategist, writer, designer, ads specialist and analyst. Some people are good at three of those. Expect the other two to suffer.
When you won't make the time. The first ninety days need hours from you: answering questions, reviewing drafts and introducing them to customers. A hire you don't have time for ends up guessing.
If any of these is true, the choice is between kinds of outside help, or doing nothing yet. Here's how to match the help to the problem.
Hire to run the answer, not to find it.
What it costs
If you're weighing a salary against outside help, I've put in-house, consultant, agency and fractional CMO costs side by side.
Not sure which problem you're looking at? The Quick Read is free and takes three minutes. It tells you whether it's the look, the message or something else. Take the Quick Read
Read next: What is a fractional CMO, and do you need one? · Why isn't my marketing working? · How much does a marketing consultant cost?