Hiring a B2B marketing consultant: what to look for

What to look for in a B2B marketing consultant: someone who starts with how committees and procurement buy, and how a stranger finds and checks you.

TL;DR

A good B2B marketing consultant starts with how your buyers buy, before saying a word about channels. B2B buyers are committees and procurement teams. They take months, and they check you before they ever call. For years the people who knew you did that checking for them. When those people retire or move on, the new ones check you through search, your website and your paperwork. That's where they decide.

A consultant who opens with a content calendar is solving a reach problem. Most established B2B firms that stall have a different one: a buyer who has never heard of you can't find you, or can't confirm you're safe to shortlist. Hire the person who asks about that first.

Related: Agency, consultant or fractional CMO? · What a small business marketing consultant does · How much does a marketing consultant cost?

The short answer

Look for someone who asks how your buyers buy before they talk about channels. Who sits on the buying committee, who signs, what procurement needs to see, how long a deal takes and who carries your reputation today.

Then look for someone who can tell you, from the outside, what a stranger in that buying group finds when they look you up. If the first meeting is about how often to post on LinkedIn, keep looking.

What I think

B2B buyers check you before they call you. By the time an engineer or a procurement lead sends a request for quote, they've already cut the list. You never see the cut. You see fewer RFQs, or RFQs for the jobs nobody else wanted, and it feels like the market went quiet.

So the most useful thing a B2B consultant does early is stand where your buyer stands and look. What comes up when they search for the thing you make? What does the site tell them in the first minute? Can they find the certification they need without emailing you?

Most owners have never seen their company from that side, because they've never had to. The people who bought from them already knew them.

Plenty of good consultants start with channels, and sometimes that's right. If buyers already find you, trust you and pick you, and there just aren't enough of them, more reach is the answer. Here's how to tell when it is. I wouldn't start there in B2B, because the expensive mistake is paying to send more strangers to a company they can't check.

Why B2B is different

Four things change what a consultant should look at first.

Committees. The person who finds you usually isn't the person who signs. An engineer shortlists, procurement compares, a program manager weighs the risk and someone senior approves. Each of them wants something different from the same website.

Procurement. Regulated buyers start by ruling suppliers out. Certifications, compliance, the industries you already serve. If they can't confirm the basics quickly, you're off the list before anyone reads a word about your quality.

Time. Deals take months. What matters is whatever is still true and still easy to find when the buyer comes back to the shortlist in month four.

People carry the reputation. In a lot of B2B firms the reputation lives in relationships: the founder, a senior salesperson, a long-time customer who mentions you to a colleague. That works well for years. Then those people retire or move on, and the reputation has to live somewhere a stranger can reach it.

None of this shows up in a channel plan. All of it shows up in who sends you the RFQ.

Nobody new could find them

The clearest case I've worked on is EST, a precision electronics manufacturer. Full disclosure: the founder is my dad, and EST was my first client. For thirty-five years reputation and referrals did the work. The customer list ran to defense primes, MedTech OEMs and aerospace integrators. The facility was built around compliance, and the company held certifications its competitors couldn't. Almost none of that was visible from the outside.

Then the people at their customers who knew them started to retire. A new generation of procurement teams searched differently and had never heard of the company. The pipeline didn't collapse. It just stopped refilling. They kept winning the buyers who already knew them. Everyone else found a competitor with a cleaner website and sent the RFQ there.

And the founder was still carrying the company's story in his head, which works right up until the company needs to run without him.

The capability was all still there. What had gone was the route a stranger used to find it. So the website was rebuilt around how those buyers arrive. A regulated buyer doesn't come looking for a list of machinery. They come asking whether you can build this, at this stage, under these requirements, without creating an expensive problem for them. The new site gives each kind of buyer a way in: paths by industry, capability as the offer and certifications in the main navigation instead of a footer. For a buyer in defense or medical devices, those aren't details. They're the first cut.

The published case study puts new sales in the first year at $2M.

What a good B2B consultant looks at first

How a buyer who has never heard of you finds you and checks you. In practice, that means questions like these:

  • What does a stranger in each buying role search for, and do you show up?
  • What does your site tell the engineer, the procurement lead and the approver, each in their first minute?
  • Are the things that rule you in (certifications, compliance, the industries you serve) easy to find, or buried?
  • Who carries your reputation today, and what happens to it if they leave?
  • Where do your RFQs come from now, and which ones are you not getting?

A good consultant will want to talk to your customers and your salespeople to answer those, not only to you. Your customers know why they picked you. Your salespeople know where deals stall.

Channels come after. Until you know where strangers drop off, a channel plan is a guess.

Questions to ask before you sign

You learn most from what a consultant asks you, but these questions help.

  • "What would you look at in the first two weeks, and what would I have at the end of them?"
  • "How will you find out how our buyers buy? Will you talk to customers?"
  • "Have you worked with buyers who go through procurement or a committee? What did you do differently?"
  • "What would you tell us to stop doing?"
  • "How will we know in ninety days whether this is working?"
  • "If the problem turns out not to be marketing, will you say so?"

Listen for the questions they ask back. If a proposal arrives before anyone has asked who signs your purchase orders, it was written for a different company.

Strategy consultant or execution?

A marketing strategy consultant decides what to fix and in what order. Execution help, whether that's an agency, a freelancer or an in-house marketer, makes the things and runs them. You need strategy first when you can't say in a sentence why the right buyers aren't finding or choosing you. You need execution when you can, and you're short of hands.

When the brief is clear, an agency is often the right call, and here's how to hire one well. When the work is permanent and the plan exists, a hire can beat any outside help, and this is what to hand them on day one. When you need someone senior to run the whole function week to week, that's a fractional CMO, and it's a different job from the one on this page.

Some strategic marketing consultants do both the thinking and the making. That can work well, as long as the diagnosis isn't shaped by what they'd like to sell you next. Ask what they'd do if the answer turned out to be something they don't offer.

If you're weighing whether to outsource B2B marketing altogether, the question is the same one at a larger size: what problem is the outside help there to solve?

What it costs

I've put consultant, agency, fractional CMO and in-house costs side by side.

Not sure which problem you're looking at? The Quick Read is free and takes three minutes. It tells you whether it's the look, the message or something else. Take the Quick Read

Read next: Agency, consultant or fractional CMO? Which one fits your problem · Thirty-five years of reputation. Nobody new could find it. · How much does a marketing consultant cost?


Not sure which problem you’re looking at?

The Quick Read is free and takes three minutes. It tells you whether it’s the look, the message or something else.

Take the Quick Read

Already know? The Outside Read is one week and $1K.