Messaging strategy: how to decide what your company says
How to build a messaging strategy: the five decisions behind what your company says, how to keep one voice everywhere and how to test it.
TL;DR
A messaging strategy is a decision before it's a document. It settles who you're for, the one thing you want them to understand, what proves it and who you're not for. Then everyone says it the same way, on the site, in sales calls and in job posts.
Most messaging struggles for an ordinary reason. It tries to keep every possible buyer in the room, so it ends up saying what anyone could say. The buyer reading it is trying to shorten a list. Give them a reason to cross some names off, yours included if you're wrong for them.
So write the simplest true thing, say it in one voice and let it sort people. The ones who lean in are the ones you wanted.
Related: What does a positioning strategy consultant do? · How to write a value proposition · Three reasons, three buyers
The short answer
What is a messaging strategy? It's the set of choices behind everything a company says: who it's for, what they should come away understanding, the proof that makes that believable and who it's deliberately not for. The homepage line, the sales deck and the careers page all come after those choices.
Brand messaging, company messaging and core messaging are names for the same work at different distances. The decision underneath doesn't change.
How do you decide it? Start with the simplest true thing about the company, the thing a good customer would say back to you. Say it the same way everywhere. Then check that it puts somebody off. If nobody could disagree with it, it isn't doing any work yet.
What I think
Messaging is a decision, not a list of adjectives.
A lot of messaging documents start with a word bank. Trusted, innovative, partner, people-first. Every word is defensible. A competitor's document would have the same ones, because they describe what any good company wants to sound like. They don't say what this company has decided.
That's understandable. Saying who you're not for feels like turning away money. From inside the business every buyer looks like a possible buyer, and the safe move is to leave the door open to all of them.
The buyer sees it differently. Someone comparing three or four options is trying to get down to one. They need a reason to exclude, not another reason to include, and messaging that welcomes everyone gives them nothing to work with. So they compare on price, or they forget you.
Good messaging sorts. The right people recognize themselves in it, and the wrong people can tell quickly that it isn't for them.
It isn't for everyone
The clearest case I've worked on was in-house. In 2018 I was on the brand and content team at Success Academy, a charter school network in New York City in a very public fight, where every statement anyone made got read as a position.
Success Academy needed to hire teachers. Ordinary recruiting copy was the obvious tool: open roles, join us, apply today. It would have been well made, and it would have left out the most important fact about the job. Anyone who took it was walking into that fight. They'd defend their employer at dinner parties and read about it in the paper. On the case page I called that kind of copy "dishonest by omission." It gets people through the door and loses them in a year.
The instinct was to soften. Lead with mission, stay above it, don't give anyone ammunition. We went the other way. A public campaign was running at the same time, Kids Over Politics, which said plainly what the organization was for. I was working on both, and that's why the recruiting ended up in the same voice. It told a candidate exactly what they'd be joining.
Including that it isn't for everyone.
That line was the messaging strategy. Teachers who wanted the fight leaned in. Teachers who didn't selected themselves out, which isn't a loss. That's a filter.
The work didn't make Success Academy less controversial. As I put it on the case page, it made the controversy legible, and then let it do the sorting. The full Success Academy story.
What a messaging strategy has to decide
Five choices. Each one rules something out.
Who it's for. Describe the buyer by their situation. "Owners who've outgrown word of mouth and don't know what to say next" tells a writer far more than a company size and an industry code.
The one thing they should understand. One. Give a reader four and they'll keep one at random, rarely the one you'd have picked. It should be something a customer could say back to you in their own words. Why your customers chose you is usually where to find it.
The proof. Whatever makes the one thing believable: a story, a way of working, a result you can show. Without it the line reads as hope, and buyers can tell. How to pick the one claim you can prove.
Who it's not for. Write this down even if it never appears on the site. It keeps the other three honest. At Success Academy it was said out loud, because leaving it out gets people through the door and loses them in a year.
The words you'll stop using. Every company has a few. The adjectives from the word bank, the internal name for a service that no buyer uses, the phrase the founder has said for ten years. Listing them is how the decision reaches the copy.
If none of the five rules anything out, nothing has been decided yet.
One voice everywhere
You can't scale when every team rewrites the story.
The strategy only works if it sounds the same wherever a buyer meets it: the website, the first sales call, the proposal, the follow-up email, the job post. Most companies get the website roughly right and let the rest drift. Sales explains the business the way the founder did years ago. Hiring uses a template. Each version is reasonable on its own, and together they describe three different companies.
When people inside a company give different reasons for why customers buy, they're often describing different buyers. I wrote about that here. Sort that out before anyone writes a line, because editing won't make three positions sound like one.
Hiring is the place most people forget. At Success Academy the recruiting and the public campaign ran as one voice. A candidate heard the same thing the public did.
At a larger company, this is what a written messaging framework is for: one source every department works from. Here's what that looked like at Viasat. For a smaller business it can be a single page. What matters is that sales, the site and hiring are all reading from it.
Your best salesperson is a good place to check. Listen to how they open a call. The position is often already in there, said better than the website says it.
One decision, said the same way everywhere a buyer can hear it.
How to test it
Three questions before anything goes live.
Could a competitor say it? Put your main line on a competitor's homepage in your head. If it would sit there without anyone noticing, it isn't yours yet. Go back to the proof.
Would the wrong buyer still get in touch? Picture the customer you'd most like to stop hearing from. Read the messaging as them. If they'd still call, it isn't sorting.
Can someone outside repeat it? Tell it to a customer, or a friend who doesn't know the business, and ask them to say it back a day later. What they keep is your messaging.
If it fails one, fix that before it goes anywhere.
When it's not a messaging problem
Sometimes the messaging is fine. If people who meet you understand what you do and buy, and the trouble is that too few of them find you, that's reach, and more of it is the right answer. If the site says the right thing but is hard to use, that's design. If the offer is wrong for the market, no sentence will fix it.
Some businesses don't need much sorting, either. A plumber in a small town serves most of the people who call. Their messaging should make them easy to find, easy to trust and easy to book, and that's a perfectly good strategy.
To tell which you have, follow one stranger through what you say, from the first thing they see to the moment they'd get in touch, and notice where they stop. More on finding where it breaks.
If you want to start today, put the five decisions on one page. If you can fill in who it's not for, you've done the hard part.
Not sure which problem you're looking at? The Quick Read is free and takes three minutes. It tells you whether it's the look, the message or something else. Take the Quick Read
Read next: The fight was the recruiting pitch · Why your customers chose you · Why isn't my marketing working?