Your team isn't confused. They're describing different buyers.

When a team gives five different reasons customers hire the firm, the story may not be broken. They may be describing five different buyers.

TL;DR

Five people at the same firm can give five different answers to why customers hire them. The owner hears a messaging problem. Everyone needs to get on the same page.

Maybe. Or maybe each person is describing a different customer, and each of them is right.

Those are two very different problems. One calls for a better shared story. The other calls for a decision about which customers the business actually wants. Confusing the two can mean spending money fixing a team that was telling the truth all along.

Five answers sound like confusion until someone outside the room asks who each one is about. It's hard to read the label from inside the bottle.

<iframe src="https://www.youtube.com/embed/tbaYDEGNtII" width="560" height="315"></iframe>

The Outside Read is one week with someone who isn't inside it, and one clear answer about what's stuck. Book the Outside Read

Five people, one line

A thirty-person design-build firm. This is a composite, a type of firm rather than any one company.

Offices above a cabinet shop. A conference table made from reclaimed beams, because of course it is. Every proposal, every truck door and the top of the website carry the same line: "Premier integrated partner for complex projects."

The owner wrote it with a consultant four years ago. Everyone signed off. Nobody objected. At the time, that felt like alignment.

Then, during a planning session, someone asks a simple question. Why do clients actually hire us? Five people answer.

The estimator says clients hire the firm because the number holds. What gets quoted is what gets billed, and on commercial tenant improvements that's rarer than it should be.

The lead project manager says clients hire them because they can work in occupied buildings without turning the place upside down. Medical offices that need to stay open during renovation. Schools working around a term calendar.

The designer says it's the design. Clients want something better than the general contractor down the road produces.

The business development lead says relationships. Most of the firm's work comes from three developers who have used them for years, because they know the people and trust them.

The owner says it's the integrated model. Design and construction under one roof. One contract, one point of accountability. That was the whole idea behind building the firm this way.

Five answers. The owner hears a team that has drifted from the story they agreed on, and starts planning a workshop to get everyone saying the same thing again.

Which sounds reasonable, until someone asks who each of those five people was talking about.

The obvious reading

There's a perfectly good argument for the workshop.

Inconsistent messaging is a real problem. When sales says one thing, the website another and the proposal something else entirely, buyers have to work out which version of the business to believe. A prospect who hears three different explanations in three meetings has every reason to wonder whether the firm knows what it does, or whether the people inside it agree on what they're selling.

Sometimes getting everyone aligned is exactly the right move.

But people giving different answers doesn't establish that they're confused. The important question is whether they're describing the same buyer differently, or describing different buyers accurately. In the first case, the story needs work. In the second, forcing one answer could make the story less true.

Look closer. The Quick Read: twelve questions, free.

Do the Quick Read. It's free, and it shows where your business fits. Take the Quick Read

Where the answers came from

Back in the planning session, each person is asked which client they had in mind.

The estimator was thinking of a property management company that had been burned twice by change orders elsewhere. For that client, cost certainty wasn't a nice extra. It was the whole decision.

The project manager was thinking of a dental group whose office stayed open through a six-month renovation. Losing patients while the work happened was the thing they needed to avoid.

The business development lead was thinking of those three repeat developers. They knew the firm and the people. What mattered was having someone they trusted pick up the phone.

Three different buying decisions, each attached to an actual client.

Then come the designer and the owner. Asked for the last client who chose the firm because of its design, the designer names a project from several years earlier. Asked for the last client who chose the integrated model, the owner names the same three developers the business development lead mentioned. Except those developers, when pressed, had never mentioned the integrated model at all.

That's the part that changes the conversation.

Three people were describing why current clients hire the firm. Two were describing what they believed made the firm worth hiring. All five answers could be sincere, and all five could reflect something real about the business. But they weren't supported by the same evidence. The team hadn't drifted into five competing versions of the business. They'd exposed the distance between the firm they were running and the firm some of them wanted it to be.

What each answer was protecting

It would be tempting to declare three answers right, two wrong, and call the matter settled. That would be another mistake.

The designer wasn't making something up. The firm had won work on the strength of its design before, and the designer wanted that to matter again. That's an ambition, and a legitimate one. The trouble starts only when the ambition gets presented as the reason today's customers are buying.

The owner's answer deserves the same consideration, maybe more. The integrated model wasn't a claim somebody invented for the website. It was the part of the business he built deliberately, the bet he made when he left his last firm. He may still be right. The integrated model might be exactly where the next five years of growth should come from. But that's a decision about the future, not proof of the present. A business can be built around a good idea that customers don't yet know how to value. That doesn't make the idea bad. It means there's work to do before the market chooses the firm for that reason.

Meanwhile, three people in the room had something the other two didn't: evidence from current clients. Those answers weren't necessarily better positioning. They were better-supported descriptions of why customers had already bought.

The firm could choose to pursue more occupied-building work, or cost-sensitive property managers, or double down on its developer relationships. It could also decide to build a market for its design or its integrated model. Those choices just shouldn't be made by pretending all five answers have already been proven. The evidence says where the firm stands. The ambition says where the owner might take it. Both matter. They aren't the same thing.

The line nobody could argue with

Which brings the conversation back to "Premier integrated partner for complex projects."

Four years ago, everyone agreed with it. Of course they did. The estimator could see cost certainty in "premier." The project manager could see occupied-building work in "complex projects." The owner could see his business model in "integrated." The designer and the business development lead could each find room in it too. Nobody had to give anything up.

That's why a line like this survives four years of approvals. It doesn't force a choice. It lets everyone keep their own version of the business, and from inside the company that looks like agreement.

From outside, it's a sentence that asks the buyer to do all the work. Premier according to whom? Integrated in a way that matters to which customer? Complex compared with what? None of those words tells the property manager whether the number will hold, or the dental group whether patients can keep coming through the door. None explains why those three developers keep coming back.

The line is broad enough to contain all five answers and specific enough to prove none of them. Too many truths and no organising truth.

And there's a more consequential problem underneath it. The customer the owner wants to attract isn't necessarily the customer the business currently serves. When a website leads with the integrated model while most of the work comes from repeat developers who value a trusted phone call, the firm is presenting its ambition as its track record.

Why the owner reads it as drift

The owner has reasons for wanting everyone behind the line. He wrote it. He paid for it. He's spent four years defending it in front of clients. And the integrated model isn't just a marketing claim to him. It's the thing he chose to do differently when he left his last company. When his own people describe why clients hire them without mentioning it, that's hard to hear. It can sound as though the bet he made doesn't matter.

That's not what the answers establish. The integrated model may be what makes the work possible. It may be a real operational advantage. None of that proves it's why clients choose the firm. A company can deliver value through one thing and get hired because of another. The owner can be right about what makes the business work while the team is right about what makes customers buy.

That's the conversation worth having. The workshop he was planning would have settled a different question. It would have reminded everyone which version of the business they were supposed to repeat, and buried the very information he needed.

What it costs, besides money

The cost isn't the workshop fee. It's what gets lost when the team leaves the room.

The estimator knows something valuable about property managers. The project manager knows something valuable about occupied-building clients. The business development lead knows why those developers keep coming back. A workshop would push those different truths into one approved sentence, and then everyone goes back to work and keeps talking about what works with the clients in front of them. Only now, in meetings, they know which answer the owner wants to hear.

That's a bigger problem than inconsistent messaging. It teaches people that the point of a planning conversation is to demonstrate agreement with the person running it. The owner ends up getting the same answer from everyone while the reasons customers buy haven't changed. He had five people willing to tell him what they believed, and three of them brought evidence that could help him make a better decision about growth. Treating that difference as disloyalty would be a poor trade.

What it turns into

This firm doesn't need to begin with a better line. It needs a decision.

Does the owner want more property managers who care about cost certainty? More occupied-building projects where keeping operations running decides the job? More work from developers who already trust the firm? Those are three directions, each with evidence behind it, each leading to a different explanation of why the business deserves to be chosen.

Or does he want to move the firm toward design-led work and the integrated model he believes in? That's a legitimate choice too. It simply starts from a different place, because the recent buyer evidence doesn't yet show the integrated model closing the deal.

The decision belongs to the owner. The team can't settle the firm's future by voting on which explanation sounds best. But the owner can't make the decision well if he dismisses their experience as confusion.

What makes this situation interesting is how much the firm already had. A property manager who chose it for cost certainty. A dental group that stayed open through a six-month renovation. Three developers whose continued business said something about trust. A history of winning work through design. And an owner with a clear belief about the company he wanted to build.

The team wasn't confused. Three people were describing customers the firm already had. Two were describing the firm they wanted it to become. Nobody needed to win that argument. The owner needed to know which was which, and the answer was already sitting around the table.


Want a read on your own business? The Outside Read is one week and one clear answer about what's actually stuck. Book the Outside Read

Read next: Viasat, one framework for four businesses · Some of your customers are being paid for by the others · The messaging was never working


Not sure which problem you’re looking at?

The Quick Read is free and takes three minutes. It tells you whether it’s the look, the message or something else.

Take the Quick Read

Already know? The Outside Read is one week and $1K.