What does a positioning strategy consultant do, and when do you need one?

What a brand strategy consultant actually changes, when one is worth hiring, when you just need the work made and what to ask before you sign.

TL;DR

A good positioning consultant changes what buyers understand you to be. Then they make sure your site, your proposals and your sales conversations all carry that understanding. The logo can wait. The hard part is seeing what you actually sell, because the people running a business are usually too close to it to see it cleanly. That doesn't mean you're behind. And a strong reputation won't fix it on its own. Plenty of respected businesses still get compared on price.

So hire one when good buyers compare you to cheaper options or can't say what you do after a first conversation. Don't hire one when the story is already clear and you need it made. That's a job for a designer, a writer or an agency, and they'll do it better.

Related: Why your customers really chose you · The positioning hiding in your sales calls · Why isn't my marketing working?

The short answer

What does a brand strategy consultant do? The title covers a lot of different work, so here's the version worth paying for. They find out how your best buyers understand you. They name what you actually sell, which is often not quite what you think you sell. They check it against the buyers it should put off. Then they carry it into everything a buyer reads: the homepage, the product pages, the proposal and the first sales call.

You'll also see the job called brand consultant, brand strategist or positioning consultant. The names overlap. What matters is whether the person changes how buyers understand you or only how you look.

It's worth it when good buyers compare you on price or can't repeat what you do. It isn't worth it when the story is clear and you need it made. That's design or execution, and you should spend the money there.

What I think

Most owners I talk to about positioning know something is off before they can say what. They feel it in sales conversations. Good prospects ask about price before they ask about the work. Or they compare you to a competitor who doesn't do what you do.

The natural reading is that the business needs more marketing or a new look. Usually it needs neither yet. What's missing is a clear statement of what the business sells, and it's missing because it's hard to see from inside. You know every detail of the work, so you describe the work. Buyers are paying for what the work does for them, and that part has become so obvious to you that you've stopped saying it.

That isn't a failing, and it doesn't mean you're behind. You're too close to see it cleanly. That's most of the reason an outside strategist is useful at all.

A good reputation doesn't solve it either. A business can be known and respected and still get grouped with cheaper options, because being known for quality isn't the same as being understood as something different. A reputation is not a position.

Selling the wrong thing

One example from my own work is The New York Times licensing business. I came in as a brand and content strategist, working with T Brand Studio, as part of a team looking at what the business could become. Licensing, or syndication, sold Times content to other publishers. The move from print to digital subscriptions had left it behind. The market was shrinking and the competitors left in it were selling similar content for less.

Buyers saw the offer as content. Premium content, trusted content, but still content. And content gets compared on price, swapped for something cheaper and bought through procurement. Marketing it better wouldn't have changed that, because the thing being marketed was understood as a commodity.

So the useful question was a different one. When people stop trusting what they read, what does the Times actually provide? Not articles. Verification: sourcing standards, editorial rigor, fact checking and the ability to correct the record. That is much harder to copy than a story.

That changed the rest of the work. The market was reframed around enterprise buyers, with use cases mapped across finance, healthcare, technology, compliance and communications. The language of the category changed with it. Then the licensing site was redesigned around the new understanding, and I wrote headlines and product copy across the catalog. Each column, podcast and magazine had to explain its value to a buyer instead of simply describing what it was.

Before, the business was a premium content supplier. After, it was a verification layer inside someone else's decisions, products and workflows. Same asset, different understanding of its value.

The journalism was never the problem. The business had been selling the visible output instead of the value underneath it. The full Times story.

What a good one does, in order

The order matters more than the deliverables.

They listen to buyers first. You matter, but your buyers matter more: the people who chose you, the ones who nearly didn't and if possible the ones who went elsewhere. Their reasons are often missing from your site. You can start on this yourself by asking customers why they chose you.

They name what you actually sell. One sentence, about the buyer's problem rather than your process. At the Times that was verification. It should feel a little uncomfortable, because it leaves things out. The sentence is often already being said somewhere, usually in your sales calls.

They check it against who it should put off. A real position makes some buyers less interested. If it appeals to everyone you could ever sell to, it hasn't decided anything yet. When the Times offer changed, the buyer changed with it.

They carry it into everything a buyer reads. The site, the product pages, the proposals and the way a first call opens. This is the step most strategy work skips. At the Times the same thinking had to hold at the level of individual product copy.

If a consultant hands you a document and leaves before the last step, you have a decision nobody has acted on.

Strategist, designer or agency?

They make different things, and most growing businesses need more than one of them at some point.

A strategist makes a decision and the words that carry it: what you sell, who it's for and how it should be said. A designer makes how it looks, from the identity to the site and the sales material. An agency makes things at volume over time, such as campaigns, content and ads. Many good ones also have strategy and design under one roof.

None of these is the better choice in general. If you know what you sell and buyers get it, a good agency or designer is the right call, and a strategist would be an expensive detour. If buyers keep misreading you, new design or more campaigns will carry the same misreading further.

I do the positioning work myself and bring in specialists by project for design and build. If you're weighing the wider options, an agency, a consultant and a fractional CMO each assume something different about your problem, so name the problem first. If you suspect the trouble is the look and not the message, a refresh may be all you need.

Signs you need one

  • Good buyers compare you to cheaper competitors and raise price early.
  • Prospects can't say what you do after a first conversation, or they describe someone else.
  • You win when you're in the room and lose when a buyer only has your website or proposal.
  • People respect your work and still group you with businesses that do less.
  • The business has changed (a new buyer or a new service) and the way you describe it hasn't.

Signs you don't

  • Your best customers can say in a sentence why they chose you, and your site already says it.
  • You know what you want to say and need it made: a site, an identity or a campaign. That's design or execution. Hire for that.
  • Buyers understand you and buy when they find you. There just aren't enough of them. That's a reach problem, and a strategist won't fix it.

When buyers misread you, it's positioning. When they read you correctly, the money belongs in the making.

Questions to ask before you hire one

From what you've seen so far, what do you think we sell? A good strategist will have a tentative answer after one conversation and will tell you it's tentative.

Who would you talk to? If the answer is only you and your senior people, ask why. Your buyers have most of the answer.

What will we have at the end, in writing? You want a sentence about what you sell and who it's for, the reasoning behind it and what it means for the site and the sales material.

Who carries it into the site and the sales material? They might do it themselves, bring in a specialist or brief your own people. Any of those can work. Know which before you start.

What would you leave alone? Good positioning work keeps what's already working. Be wary of anyone who wants to change everything.

What it costs

It depends on the scope and how the work is priced, so I've put consultant, agency, fractional CMO and in-house costs side by side.

Where to start

Before you talk to anyone, try writing one sentence: what your best buyers get from you that they couldn't easily get somewhere cheaper. If it comes easily and your site already says it, you may not need a strategist. If you can't write it, or you can and no buyer would recognize it, that's the work.

If you'd like to talk about yours, here's how working with me starts.

Not sure which problem you're looking at? The Quick Read is free and takes three minutes. It tells you whether it's the look, the message or something else. Take the Quick Read

Read next: Selling the wrong thing: The New York Times · Messaging strategy: how to decide what your company says · How to write a value proposition, starting from what you already say


Not sure which problem you’re looking at?

The Quick Read is free and takes three minutes. It tells you whether it’s the look, the message or something else.

Take the Quick Read

Already know? The Outside Read is one week and $1K.