How to write a value proposition, starting from what you already say
How to write a value proposition without a template: start from what you already say, cross out what your category claims and test what's left.
TL;DR
Your value proposition is probably already in something you've said. Listen to how you explain the business when you're explaining it well, and to what your best customers say about why they chose you. Then look at what everyone else in your category says and find the part they leave out. Write that part as one plain sentence about the buyer's situation.
Here's the turn. A good one puts some buyers off. A sentence every buyer agrees with gives none of them a reason to pick you. The buyer needs a reason to exclude, not another reason to include.
Before you use it, test it three ways. Could a competitor sign it? Would anyone be put off? Can a customer repeat it?
Related: Why your customers really chose you · The one thing you can prove · What a positioning strategy consultant does
The short answer
A value proposition is the reason a particular buyer should choose you over their other options, including doing nothing. That's the only definition you need.
To write one, start from what you already say rather than from a formula. Collect your own best explanation of the business and your customers' reasons for choosing you. Cross out everything your competitors already claim. What's left is your raw material. Turn it into one sentence about the buyer's situation, in words they'd use, and check that it rules some buyers out.
The sentence you end up with should be true of you, useful to the buyer and awkward for most competitors to claim.
What I think
Templates produce sentences any competitor could sign.
The formulas are popular for a fair reason. They make you name a customer, a need and a benefit, and that beats a blank page. The trouble is what comes out the other end. Fill in the same blanks as everyone else in your category and you get the same sentence with your name on it.
What makes a value proposition work is rarely the wording. It's a choice about what to talk about. Most owners have already made that choice without noticing, in how they describe the work when someone asks.
So I think of it as something you find. The writing is the last ten minutes. Finding it is the rest.
The reason was already there
Peak Value is a business brokerage. The founder had been at a larger international brokerage and left to start his own firm. That raised a fairly obvious question for any owner thinking about selling a company: why choose him instead?
Most of his category answers with the transaction. Listings, valuation, multiples, closing. Those things matter, and every broker can talk about them, which is exactly why they don't help an owner choose.
He talked about something else. He cared about the owner, specifically someone who had spent thirty years building a business and was now thinking about letting it go. What they were actually walking away from. Whether the business was ready to be sold in the first place.
That became the position: Exit Readiness. The case page puts it this way: "Not just helping owners sell businesses. Helping them get to the point where selling one actually makes sense." We built the messaging and the site around that idea.
Nobody invented a benefit or polished a slogan. The difference already existed in what he cared about and how he talked about the work. The job was to hear it, name it and then use it everywhere.
Look at who the position is about, too. Exit Readiness describes the owner's situation, the question of whether the business is ready, more than it describes the broker.
How to write one, step by step
Five steps, and only one of them is writing.
1. Listen to your own best explanation. Think of the last time you explained the business and it landed. A good first meeting, a dinner, a call where the other person leaned in. What did you say? Write it down as close to word for word as you can. Better still, record yourself explaining the business to someone who doesn't know it, and listen back for the part where you got animated. That part is usually the one to keep. It's often sitting in your sales calls already, and here's how to find it there.
2. Ask customers why they chose you. Ask why they picked you over the alternatives at the moment they decided, rather than what they like about working with you. Their reasons are often different from yours. Where the two overlap is usually where the value proposition is. How to ask so you get a real answer.
3. List what the category says, then cross it out. Open five competitors' websites and write down every claim on their homepages. Experience, quality, service, responsiveness, local knowledge. Anything on that list is something buyers have already heard several times this week. Cross it out of your own notes. What's left is the part only you are saying. For Peak Value, the crossed-out list was the transaction. What was left was the owner.
4. Write one sentence about the buyer's situation. Describe the situation the buyer is in when they need you and what changes for them. Leave your process and your years in business out of it. Use the words a customer would use, which you collected in step two. If the sentence needs three clauses to hold together, you haven't chosen yet. Pick one.
5. Test it. Three tests, below.
One thing these steps won't tell you is whether you can prove the difference you've found. That's its own question, and I've written about it separately.
Three tests
A sentence that passes all three on the first try is rare. That's normal.
Could a competitor sign it? Swap your name for a competitor's and read it again. If it's still true, it isn't yours yet. "Trusted, experienced and client-focused" is true of almost everyone, so it tells a buyer nothing. The same test applied to a real estate line.
Would someone be put off? This is the test owners push back on. A good value proposition makes some buyers think "that's not for me", and that's what it's for. If nobody could disagree with the sentence, nobody will choose you because of it. It should send the wrong buyers somewhere else and give the right ones a reason to stay.
Can a customer repeat it? Read it to a customer. A week later, ask them what you do. If what they say is close, it works. If they turn it into something different, listen carefully. Their version may be the better one.
If it passes, stop editing. If it fails, go back to step three before you reach for a thesaurus.
Where it goes
A value proposition only earns anything once it's in front of buyers. Three places matter most.
- The homepage. The first line a stranger reads should be the sentence, or close to it. They should know within a few seconds whether this is for them.
- Proposals. Put it in the opening paragraph, before the scope and the price. It reminds the buyer why they're talking to you at all.
- How sales opens. It's the first thing you say when someone asks what you do. If you and whoever else sells for you describe the business differently, buyers hear two different businesses.
Use the same words in all three places, so a buyer hears it more than once and in the same form.
If you want to carry it further, into everything the company says, that's a messaging question, and I've written about how to decide it.
When you can't find it yourself
Sometimes you do every step and the sentence still won't come. That's common, and it usually has nothing to do with your writing.
You're close to the business, which makes it hard to hear what's unusual about it. What feels ordinary to you, because you do it every day, is often the part buyers can't get anywhere else.
That's when an outside ear helps. Someone listens to you explain the business, talks to a few of your customers and tells you which of the things you already say is the one. What that kind of consultant does, and when one is worth it. If you're weighing what outside help costs, I've put consultant, agency, fractional CMO and in-house costs side by side.
Before any of that, it's worth knowing whether the message is the problem at all.
Not sure which problem you're looking at? The Quick Read is free and takes three minutes. It tells you whether it's the look, the message or something else. Take the Quick Read
Read next: A calendar full of people who weren't ready · Messaging strategy: how to decide what your company says · The positioning hiding in your sales calls