One factory, several industries: how a manufacturer should present itself

Manufacturing branding across several industries: one structure, a few shared pillars and the proof each market's buyers check first.

TL;DR

A manufacturer that sells into defense, aerospace and medical devices has two easy options, and both go wrong. One message for every market sounds consistent and lands with nobody in particular. A separate identity for each market sounds tailored, and the company behind them gets harder to see.

The answer sits between the two. Decide what the company believes and promises, pick a few pillars every market shares and then write the version each industry hears, led by the proof that industry checks first. Then write down which parts can change and which can't.

Manufacturing branding is mostly a decision about what stays the same. Get that right and each market can have its own version without the company coming apart.

Related: How to choose a marketing agency for a manufacturing company · SEO for manufacturers · Messaging strategy

The short answer

Don't force one message on every market, and don't split into separate identities for each. Build one structure: what the company believes and promises, a few shared pillars and then the version each industry needs, with the proof that industry checks first. A defense buyer and a medical device buyer can share a factory and nothing about how they buy. The structure lets each of them hear what matters to them and still recognize the same company.

What I think

For a manufacturer, branding is mostly a decision about what stays the same.

Most owners hear the word and think of the logo, the colors and maybe a tagline. Those matter. But for a company with more than one market, the harder question is how much of the story should match when the defense side and the medical side each describe the company.

Of course each side has developed its own way of talking. It should have. The people selling to a prime know what a prime needs to hear, and the people selling to a device OEM know something different. Nothing is wrong with that. The trouble starts when nobody has decided which parts of the story belong to the whole company, so every new capabilities sheet, trade show booth and web page reopens the question.

If you sell into one industry, most of this page is more than you need. One clear message, said well and backed by the right certifications, will carry you a long way.

Four businesses, one company

The clearest version of this problem I've worked on was at Viasat, a satellite company with four major businesses: defense, commercial aviation, enterprise broadband and telecom. I was in-house there, on the brand and content team, so I saw it from the inside rather than as an outside adviser. Each business had its own buyer, its own priorities and its own version of the company story. As the case page puts it, "A government program officer should not hear the same message as an airline executive."

Those differences were legitimate. The problem was that they didn't add up from the outside. The company's own investor research said so: analysts understood the part of the business they covered, but not always how the whole company fit together. Inside, it showed up as recurring debate over language. Outside, it showed up as complexity.

So we didn't make the divisions sound the same. We built one structure they could all work from. At the top sat the company's belief and its promise. Under that were three shared pillars: People, Products & Services and Principles. Each pillar had a common truth the whole company could stand behind, with yearly themes underneath to guide what people actually talked about.

Then each business got its own messaging inside that structure. For enterprise and mobility, the customer's problem was reliable connectivity in difficult places, and the proof was decades of connecting customers across land, sea, air and space. For commercial aviation the structure stayed the same, but the buyer changed. Airline leaders needed confidence that the connectivity had already been proven at scale, so the proof changed too: aircraft connected, airline relationships and operating history.

The hard part was adoption. Because we were in-house, the work didn't end with a presentation. The messaging was developed with the people in each division who'd have to use it in campaigns, sales materials and internal communications. It also came with decision rules: what stays fixed, what can change and what needs review. That cut down the number of times a new piece of work turned into another argument about the fundamentals.

The full case is here.

The divisions didn't need to sound identical. They needed to sound like the same company.

The two easy answers, and why they fail

One message for every market. It's tidy, it's easy to maintain and it looks consistent. What it usually costs is relevance. A line written to work for an aerospace integrator and a device OEM at once tends to fall back on quality, precision and partnership, which every competitor also claims. Each buyer reads it and finds nothing about their own requirements.

A separate identity for each market. Each division sounds credible to its own buyers, and that's a real benefit. But the parent company gets harder to understand. A procurement lead who buys for two programs, a prime looking for a supplier with range or a new hire trying to work out what the company does can't see how the pieces relate. The strengths you share across markets (the quality system, the engineering depth, the years of history) stop adding up and start getting split.

One message loses the buyer. Separate identities lose the company.

What stays fixed and what flexes

Four layers. The first two rarely change. The last two are where each market gets its own version.

  1. What the company believes and promises. One or two sentences that are true in every industry you serve. If it only fits one market, it isn't the top layer.
  2. A few shared pillars. Three is plenty. Each one is something every division can back with proof: how you run quality, how you engineer, how you treat customers.
  3. The version each industry hears. The same shape with different content: the buyer's problem in their words, what's at stake for them and the proof they check first.
  4. Decision rules. Who can change what. The belief and the pillars stay fixed. Headlines, examples and proof flex by market. Anything that touches the top two layers goes to review.

Write it down in a page or two. The test is whether a salesperson in one division can put together a new capabilities sheet without calling a meeting about what the company stands for.

The top stays put. The bottom is where each market gets its say.

Selling into defense, aerospace and MedTech from the same floor

This is where a lot of multi-market manufacturers live, and it's where the third layer does most of its work. Each of these buyers checks something different first, usually before reading a word about quality.

  • Defense. Whether you can handle controlled work at all: ITAR registration, security requirements and the primes and programs you already support.
  • Aerospace. Your quality system and traceability. AS9100 is often the first cut, then first-article inspection and process control.
  • Medical devices. Whether your quality system will hold up around a regulated device: ISO 13485, FDA expectations, documentation and change control.

Same factory, same people, often the same machines. Three different first questions.

EST, a precision electronics manufacturer, is the pattern in one line. Full disclosure: the founder is my dad, and EST was my first client. Part of the work was buyer-specific proof sheets for defense, MedTech and aerospace, because, as the case page says, these are "buyers who share a factory and nothing about how they buy."

The same layer shapes the rest. On the website, it means giving each industry its own way in. In search, those certifications are also what procurement types into the box.

Lead with what each buyer checks first. The rest of the story can follow.

When it's a rebrand and when it's structure

If the company looks dated, the name confuses people or the identity no longer fits what you've become, that's a rebrand question, and here's how to tell a refresh from a rebrand. Sometimes that really is the job, and a new look does a lot of work in a market that judges suppliers quickly.

If the look is fine and the problem is that each market tells a different story about the company, a new logo won't settle it. That's a structure job, and it's mostly writing. More on messaging strategy here.

Sometimes it's both. Do the structure first. A new identity is easier to design when you know what it has to carry.

Who to hire for it

A manufacturing branding agency can do this well, especially the design and the rollout across the site, the sales sheets and the trade show materials. I've been on the agency side, and the good ones ask about your markets and your buyers before they show you a logo. Judge them on that, and here's how to choose one. If you want the thinking settled before anything gets designed, that's closer to a brand strategy consultant.

What it costs

It depends on how many markets you serve and how much needs making, and I've put consultant, agency, fractional CMO and in-house costs side by side.

Where to start

Write the top two layers on one page. Then, for each industry you sell into, write the first thing that buyer checks and where on your site they'd find it. If those answers come easily, you're most of the way there. If they don't, that's the job.

Keep the top fixed. Let each market have the rest.

Not sure which problem you're looking at? The Quick Read is free and takes three minutes. It tells you whether it's the look, the message or something else. Take the Quick Read

Read next: Viasat: you can't scale when everybody rewrites the story · Website design for manufacturers: build it around how buyers arrive · Rebrand or refresh? How to tell which one you need


Not sure which problem you’re looking at?

The Quick Read is free and takes three minutes. It tells you whether it’s the look, the message or something else.

Take the Quick Read

Already know? The Outside Read is one week and $1K.