Thinking about a website redesign? Decide what it has to do first.

Thinking about a website redesign? Decide what the site has to do, who it's for and how you'll know it worked before anyone quotes the build.

TL;DR

Start with the brief, not the build. Before anyone quotes you for a new website, write down what it has to do, who it's for and how you'll know it's working. That page decides the scope, most of the cost and whether you need a redesign, a rebrand or neither.

The site is usually where a problem shows up, which is why a new one looks like the answer from inside the business. Sometimes it is the answer. A site that can't be maintained, can't be found or was built for a business you no longer run needs rebuilding. But if the trouble starts further up, in what you say or who you say it to, a new site gives you a better-looking version of the same problem. The brief is how you tell which one you have.

Related: Do you need a new website? · What a website redesign costs · Redesign without losing your rankings

The short answer

Write one page before you talk to anyone who builds websites. It answers three questions.

What does the site have to do that it doesn't do now? Who is it for, and what are they trying to find out when they land on it? What would tell you, a few months after launch, that it worked?

Those answers set the scope, and the scope sets most of the price. They tell you whether this is a redesign, a rebrand or a smaller fix. And they decide whether the new site is better or just newer.

What I think

The website is usually where the problem shows, not where it starts.

From inside a business, the site is the most visible thing that looks wrong. It's dated, a competitor's looks sharper or a prospect said something about it on a call. Those things are often true. Of course a new site looks like the answer. It's the one problem you can see, point at and get a quote for.

But a site can only say what the business has already decided to say. If nobody has settled who it's for and why they should choose you over the firm down the road, the designer settles it for you, by default, in the first meeting. You get a good-looking site built around a guess.

That's why the expensive part of a redesign is the brief. The build is a known cost. A brief that answers the wrong question costs the build and then the next one.

The brief that was a feeling

Grand Union is a Portland real estate business led by Tyler Koski and his co-owner, Michael. They came to me wanting more social media. Over the time we worked together, that grew into a new website and the CRM behind it.

When the website came up, Michael gave me the brief in one sentence. It was a feeling, not a scope: "whoever looks at us, whether it's a customer, an agent or a competitor, they understand exactly who, what and where we are and why we do what we do."

That's how most owners describe what they want, and it's a good start. A designer can't build "understand exactly who we are," though. Someone has to turn it into decisions.

Taken apart, the sentence held the decisions. "Whoever looks at us" meant buyers, sellers and agents, each looking for something different. Michael put the navigation question better than I could: "I'm a buyer. What am I looking for? I'm a seller. What am I looking for?" "Where we are" became neighborhoods. The site made them the front door, with a price page for each neighborhood that's updated every month.

Then the brief got smaller. After walking through the whole site, Michael reduced it to one mechanic: "if a client wants to get a hold of us, they need to be able to push a button, and we have to be able to know that and call them." A fast way to reach them, and a fast call back, was the only website feature the owners fought for. Everything else they were happy to leave for later.

The feeling told us what the site was for. The button told us what it had to do.

The fair objection: "websites don't matter"

Tyler wasn't sure any of it mattered. Early on he told me: "I've heard multiple people that are very successful in real estate say, your website does not matter. And I kind of believe it." Later he put it more precisely: "most clients don't care about the web page. They care about the relationship with their agent."

He was mostly right, and it's worth saying where. In a business that runs on relationships, almost nobody chooses you because of your website. They choose the person. If a redesign is meant to make people pick you, it usually won't.

Where I'd push back is on what happens before the relationship starts. Someone hears your name from a friend and looks you up. The site won't win them, but it can lose them, if they can't tell what you do or can't reach you quickly. That's why the one feature the owners fought for was the button. The site's job was to get a stranger to the relationship and then get out of the way.

He was right about what the site couldn't do. That's what made its one job clear.

The website redesign process, in order

Most redesign proposals start at design and stop at launch. The order that holds up adds two steps before design and one after launch.

  1. Decide what the site has to do, who it's for and what would count as working. One page, in plain words.
  2. Check that the problem really is the site. Ask a few recent customers why they chose you, and watch someone who's never heard of you try to use the current one. If the problem is in what you say, a new site won't reach it.
  3. Brief the builder with the decision, not with a list of sites you admire. Give them the one page and ask them to quote against it.
  4. Build to the brief. When a choice comes up that the brief doesn't answer, go back to the brief before you go to taste.
  5. Measure against what you said would count as working. Set up tracking before launch, so you have a before to compare the after with.

The first two steps are cheap and quick, and they're the ones that get skipped. The last one is the only way to know whether the money did anything.

Redesign, rebrand or neither

The brief usually answers this for you.

If buyers understand what you do and choose you, but the site is hard to update, hard to find or built for an older version of the business, you need a redesign. Those are the reasons for a website redesign that hold up, and that page lets the redesign win.

If buyers keep comparing you with the wrong firms, or can't say what you do, a new site won't reach it. That's a question about what the business stands for, and the answer might be a rebrand or a lighter refresh. Here's how to tell which.

Sometimes the answer is neither. The site works and people find it, but the wrong ones call. That has its own fix, and it isn't a rebuild. More on a website that brings the wrong jobs.

A redesign changes what the site can do. A rebrand changes what it has to say.

What it costs and what can go wrong

For a small or mid-sized business, web design work typically runs $6.5K to $50K, by WebFX's survey of 250 US marketing professionals (updated October 2026). What drives that number, and what a quote leaves out.

A rebrand is priced differently. Most branding projects reviewed on Clutch sit between $10K and $50K, by Clutch's verified client review data (September 2026). What that money actually buys.

The thing that goes wrong most quietly is search. A new site that changes your page addresses without redirecting the old ones can lose rankings that took years to earn. How to redesign without losing them.

The quote tells you what the build costs. The brief decides whether it was worth it.

Where to go from here

If you're still deciding whether you need a new site at all, start with whether it really is the website. If you're holding a quote, what a website redesign costs walks through what's in it. If the question is bigger than the site, read rebrand or refresh, then what a rebrand costs and how to rebrand without losing what already works. Before anything launches, read how to redesign without losing your search rankings. And if you're deciding who to hire, start with where to go for a site or a rebrand.

Whichever you read first, write the one page before you call anyone.

Not sure which problem you're looking at? The Quick Read is free and takes three minutes. It tells you whether it's the look, the message or something else. Take the Quick Read

Read next: Do you need a new website? · Rebrand or refresh? · Grand Union


Not sure which problem you’re looking at?

The Quick Read is free and takes three minutes. It tells you whether it’s the look, the message or something else.

Take the Quick Read

Already know? The Outside Read is one week and $1K.