How do you rebrand a business without losing what already works?

How to rebrand your business in the right order: decide what's true, test it with buyers, write the rules, then design, roll out and tell customers first.

TL;DR

Do it in order, and leave the logo until step four. First decide what's true about the business and who it's for. Test that with the buyers you want. Write it down as rules the people who'll use it can follow without you. Then design. Then change everything that carries the name, and tell the people who already know you before you tell the market.

Most rebrands start with the look because the look is what you can see. The rules are the rebrand. The look is how the rules show, and once the rules are settled it's the easier part to get right.

Related: Thinking about a website redesign? Decide what it has to do first. · How much does a rebrand cost? · Rebrand or refresh?

The short answer

In this order: decide what's true and who it's for, test it with buyers, write the rules everyone will use, then design, then roll out to everything that carries the name, then tell the people who already know you before you tell anyone else.

Most rebrands go wrong by starting at step four. A designer is the easiest person to hire and a new logo is the easiest thing to approve, so that's where the money goes first. The first three steps cost mostly time and attention, and they decide whether the design has anything to carry.

What I think

If you're thinking about a rebrand, you're probably right that something has to change. The name no longer fits what you sell, the site looks like it belongs to an older company or a competitor looks sharper in the same meeting. Of course the look is where you'd start. It's the part everyone can see.

But a rebrand is a set of decisions about what the business is and who it's for. The logo, the colors and the website are where those decisions show up. If nobody makes the decisions first, the designer makes them for you, by taste, and you approve them by taste too.

So I treat the rules as the rebrand and the design as the rules made visible. When the rules are clear, the design brief is short and the rounds of revisions are about craft. When they aren't, the revisions turn into arguments about strategy.

The order, step by step

1. Decide what's true and who it's for. Write down what the business is, who it's for and why those buyers choose you over whatever else they'd do. Use what customers actually say when they recommend you. If your best salesperson and your website describe the business differently, settle which one is right before anything else happens.

2. Test it with buyers. Take that description to a handful of the buyers you want and a few you already have. Ask them to tell you back what you do. If they can't, or they say it in a way that would lose you the job, go back to step one. This is the cheapest place in the whole process to find out you're wrong.

3. Write the rules. Turn it into something people can use without you in the room: what stays fixed, what each kind of buyer hears, which proof goes with which buyer and what needs a second look before it goes out. Write it for the salesperson and the person putting together next year's proposal, not only for the designer.

4. Design. Now brief the designer. The brief can be short because the hard decisions are already made. The designer's job is to make the rules visible, consistent and easy to recognize. Taste still matters here. It just isn't deciding the strategy anymore.

5. Roll out to everything that carries the name. The website, proposals, the sales deck, email signatures, invoices, LinkedIn, directory listings, signage, vehicles. Make the full list before launch and change as much of it as you can in one push. A business whose website tells the new story while its proposals tell the old one reads as two companies. If the name or the web addresses are changing, map every old address to its new one before launch. Here's how to keep your search rankings through the change.

6. Tell the people who already know you first. Staff, then customers, then partners and suppliers, then the market. The people who know you are the ones carrying your reputation. If they find out from a press release or a new logo on an invoice, the first thing they wonder is what went wrong. Tell them what's changing, what isn't and why it's good for them.

Each step makes the next one smaller. Skip one and its work lands on the step after it.

Four businesses, one story

The clearest version of this I've worked on was at Viasat. I did this work in-house in 2021, with Viasat's brand and content team. Viasat had four businesses: defense, commercial aviation, enterprise broadband and telecom. Each had its own buyer and its own way of describing the company. Investor research found analysts understood the segments they covered but not how the whole company fit together. Inside, the same wording got debated again and again.

There were two obvious ways out, and both were rejected. One corporate message for everyone would have said too little to any one buyer. The other was fully independent brands for each division.

What got built sat between the two. A belief and a promise for the whole company. Three pillars every business shared. Messaging for each audience, where the structure stayed the same and the buyer, the issue and the proof changed. And decision rules: what stays fixed, what can change and what needs review, so a team making one asset didn't have to reopen the fundamentals to make it.

It was developed with the people who would use it. The aim was to make the framework easier to use than starting from a blank page, rather than something people had to be made to follow. The framework came first. Everything that carried the name was built from it.

The case page puts the problem in one line: "You can't scale when everybody rewrites the story." That's step three. A business with one division has the same problem on a smaller scale, every time a new salesperson writes their own pitch.

Why B2B rebranding is slower

If you sell to other businesses, give it more time than you think it needs. Your buyers don't meet you once. They meet you in a proposal, a procurement system, a reference call and a contract renewal, often months apart. Each of those carries the old name or the old story until someone changes it.

Procurement is the slow part. A new name can mean new vendor records on your customer's side, updated contracts and paperwork someone else has to redo for you. A buying committee that approved you under one description will want to know the company they approved is still the company they're paying.

And in B2B the reputation usually lives with individuals: the engineer who specified you, the buyer who has ordered from you for years. A rebrand has to reach them the way the reputation did, one person at a time.

Common mistakes and the real disadvantages

The mistakes I see most often:

Starting with the look. Covered above. It's the most common one because it's the most natural.

Rebranding to fix a problem that lives somewhere else. If leads go cold because nobody calls them back, or prospects balk at the price, a new name won't reach it. Check where buyers drop out before you decide the name is the reason.

Changing the name without a plan for what the old one earned. Search rankings, links from other sites, reviews and directory listings were all built under the old name. They don't follow you on their own.

Half a rollout. New website, old proposals. New logo, old pitch. Buyers notice the gap before you do.

Rules nobody uses. A guidelines document that reads like a compliance manual gets skipped. If the rules are harder to use than starting over, people start over.

Testing with the wrong people. You and your staff like it. The buyers were never asked.

The disadvantages are real too, and worth saying plainly. A rebrand costs more than the design line suggests, because everything that carries the name has to change. Here's what the money actually buys. It confuses some existing customers for a while. It takes time from the people who sell. And if the name changes, you put some of your search and reputation at risk.

Those costs are worth paying when buyers keep misunderstanding what you are. When buyers understand you and the look is just tired, a refresh is the smaller and safer job. How to tell which one you need.

What to keep

Before you change anything, list what's already working and protect it.

  • What customers say when they recommend you. It's usually the truest version of step one.
  • The name, if people search for it. A name buyers type into Google is hard to replace. If you do change it, redirect every old address.
  • The parts of the look people recognize, like a color or a mark. These can often be carried forward.
  • Your proof: certifications, case studies, reviews and the clients you can name.
  • The phrases your best salesperson uses that already land.

Keep what buyers use to find you and recognize you. Change what makes them misunderstand you.

Not sure which problem you're looking at? The Quick Read is free and takes three minutes. It tells you whether it's the look, the message or something else. Take the Quick Read

Read next: Rebrand or refresh? How to tell which one you need. · How do you redesign a website without losing your search rankings? · You can't scale when everybody rewrites the story


Not sure which problem you’re looking at?

The Quick Read is free and takes three minutes. It tells you whether it’s the look, the message or something else.

Take the Quick Read

Already know? The Outside Read is one week and $1K.