Do you need a new website, or a better reason for the one you have?

The good reasons to redesign a website are about what it can't do. The bad ones are about how it looks. How to tell which you have before you get a quote.

TL;DR

Redesign when the site is the thing holding the business back: you can't keep it up, buyers can't find it, it can't do a job you now depend on or it describes a business you've outgrown. When one of those is true, waiting usually costs more than building.

Looking dated, a sharper competitor and a soft quarter are weaker reasons. They're usually a message problem that shows up on the website, because the website is the easiest place to see it.

Even with a good reason, a new site can rebuild the old problem. Decide what the site has to say and do before anyone designs it.

Related: Thinking about a website redesign? · How much does a website redesign cost? · Redesigning without losing your rankings

The short answer

Redesign when the site can't be maintained, can't be found, can't do a job the business now needs or was built for a business that no longer exists. Don't redesign because it looks dated, because a competitor's looks better or because sales are down and the site is the easiest thing to change. Those three are usually a message problem showing up on the website.

What I think

The good reasons to redesign are about what the site can't do. The bad ones are about how it looks.

Some sites do need replacing. The point is to know which kind of reason you have before you ask for a quote, because the two lead to different briefs.

From the inside, a new site looks like the answer to most things. It's the most visible thing the business owns, it's often the first thing a prospect sees and it's a project with a start and an end. Of course that's where the eye goes. But your website might not be the problem. It might just be where the problem is visible.

So the useful question isn't "is our site old?" It's "what can't our site do?"

If you can name what it can't do, you have a reason. If you can only name how it looks, you have a feeling worth checking first.

Signs it really is the website

These are the reasons that hold up, and any one of them is enough.

  • You can't keep it up. Every change needs a developer, takes an afternoon or breaks something on a phone. If the people running the business can't change a sentence, the site drifts out of date whatever it looks like.
  • Buyers can't find it. The site doesn't show up when people search for what you do, and the way it's built is part of why. Some of that can be repaired in place. When the platform itself is the obstacle, it can't.
  • It can't do a job you now depend on. You need people to book, buy, compare options or reach you fast, and the site was never built for that.
  • It describes a business you've outgrown. You've added a service, changed who you sell to or moved upmarket, and the site still sells the old shape.

Each of these is about function. You could hand any one of them to a developer as a requirement.

Reasons that feel like reasons

Three reasons come up more than any others, and on their own none of them justifies a rebuild.

It looks dated. Sometimes it does, and a dated look can cost you some trust with a buyer who's comparing. But if the site is clear, kept up and found, a dated look calls for a new coat of paint, not new walls.

A competitor's site looks better. Their site is the only part of their business you can see. You don't know whether it's winning them work.

Sales are down and the site is the thing you can change. This is the one that costs the most. A drop in sales has a cause somewhere: the market, the offer, the people selling or the way the business explains itself. The site is the easiest of those to commission, so it gets the budget. If the cause is somewhere else, the new site launches into the same quarter.

All three usually point at the message. Buyers can't tell quickly what you do, who it's for or why you over the other option. A new site carries whatever message you give it, so if the message is the problem, the rebuild carries the problem over.

A dated site with a clear message still sells. A new site with an unclear one doesn't.

When the redesign is the right call

Sometimes the answer is yes, and SLATT is the clearest case I've worked on. I sit on SLATT's bench as their fractional CMO, so weigh what follows with that in mind. SLATT is two founders. Jason Slattum runs revenue. Grace Slattum runs people. Together they step into companies that have outgrown the way they're being led.

Before the work, they were building and maintaining their own site. Grace described the loop: "In WordPress, I have to then configure it for my cell phone. And I'm like, Oh my God, this is stupid." Then it would look right on the phone, "and then I put it on a bigger monitor, and I'm like, no, it looks stupid again."

The words were harder than the layout. Two experts in two disciplines were writing one site, each in the vocabulary of their own field. "We're like playing a game of telephone as far as the language to convey," Grace said.

That's two of the good reasons at once. They couldn't keep the site up without a fight over every screen size, and it couldn't do the job the business now needed, which was to explain one firm with two kinds of expertise to a buyer who only knew their own problem.

They did need a new site. Both reasons were about function, not looks.

The new site that would have rebuilt the problem

The risk with a good reason is that it rushes you past the brief.

The obvious new SLATT site was easy to picture. Split it in half: fractional chief revenue officer on one side, fractional chief people officer on the other. It would also have built two firms sharing a domain, which is exactly how the business looks when it's presented literally.

The trouble was in the market. Most fractional firms lead with the job title, and buyers don't always know which title they need. They describe conditions instead. Sales keeps missing plan. The company has outgrown its operating model. The founder is carrying too much. A buyer with a revenue problem could dismiss the people work. A buyer with a people problem could wonder why a revenue operator was on the homepage.

So the position came first. One idea sits above both disciplines: leadership that steps in. Fractional leadership, advisory and consulting became three ways to engage the same standard, not three businesses. Then the site was built around six situations that create demand, like the growth stall or the senior leader who leaves and whose role everyone else absorbs. The wider bench, across marketing, operations, finance and technology, is organized by trigger. The role comes after the condition.

The look followed the same rule. One visual system for the whole firm, so people and revenue read as equal parts of one business. As the case page puts it, "The design could not quietly recreate the split the positioning had just solved."

The case page claims no results, and neither do I.

A good reason tells you to rebuild. The brief tells you what to build.

Revamp or redesign, and how often

A revamp changes what's on the pages. A redesign changes how the site is built and organized.

A revamp is new copy, new photos or a new look on the same structure and platform. It's the right call when the site is kept up, found and doing its jobs, but looks or reads old. It costs less, it's faster and it carries less risk to your search rankings.

A redesign is new structure, new navigation and often a new platform. It's the right call when one of the four good reasons is true. It costs more, and if page addresses change it can cost you rankings too. Here's how to avoid that.

As for how often, you'll see advice that puts a number of years on it. I'd ignore the calendar. Look at the site again when the business changes: a new service, a new kind of buyer, a new way of selling or a new person doing the selling. If the site still describes the business and still does its jobs, it can be older than you'd like and still be fine.

The signs a site is outdated in a way that matters are the four above. The signs it's outdated in a way that mostly bothers you are the fonts, the photos and the fact that you've looked at it every day for years.

Revamp when it looks old. Redesign when it can't do the job.

What it isn't

Two problems look like a website problem and usually need something other than a rebuild.

If people visit and don't buy, the question is what they find when they get there: whether they can tell what you do, whether it's for them and what to do next. That's a different question from whether to rebuild, and I've answered it here.

If the site brings in inquiries but they're the wrong jobs, the site is working. It's just pointed at the wrong buyer. That one has its own page.

A rebuild won't fix either by itself. Both start with what the site says.

Before you ask for a quote

Write down, in one sentence, what the new site has to do that the current one can't. If the sentence is about function, it's the first line of your brief, and any developer will price it better for having it. If the sentence is about how the site looks or how sales feel, find out what the message is doing before you pay for the build.

Decide what it has to do. Then pay someone to make it.

Not sure which problem you're looking at? The Quick Read is free and takes three minutes. It tells you whether it's the look, the message or something else. Take the Quick Read

Read next: Thinking about a website redesign? Decide what it has to do first. · What if your website works, but brings you the wrong jobs? · Nobody was buying "fractional."


Not sure which problem you’re looking at?

The Quick Read is free and takes three minutes. It tells you whether it’s the look, the message or something else.

Take the Quick Read

Already know? The Outside Read is one week and $1K.