Nonprofit website design: what the site has to do before it looks good
A nonprofit website serves donors, the people your programs are for and volunteers at once. Decide what each one needs to do before you design it.
TL;DR
A nonprofit website serves at least three people at once: someone who might give, someone who might need the program and someone who might help as a volunteer, partner or funder. They arrive with different questions, often on the same afternoon.
Most sites try to answer all three on the homepage and end up answering none of them first. So before anyone designs anything, decide which visitor the homepage is for, what each one should be able to do in one click and what you'll measure.
The donate button isn't a strategy. It's what's left when nobody decided what the site is for.
Sometimes the site really is the problem. It can't be updated, it can't be found or it breaks on a phone. Then rebuild it, but still decide first.
Related: Nonprofit marketing strategy: find the one thing in the way first · Website redesign: decide what it has to do first · Marketing and communications for nonprofits
The short answer
A nonprofit site serves at least three people at once: someone who might give, someone who might need the program and someone who might help (a volunteer, a partner or a funder). Decide which one the homepage is for, what each should be able to do in one click and what you'll measure. Then design.
That order matters more for a nonprofit than for most businesses, because a business site usually has one visitor who might buy. Yours has three who want different things from you, and one of them may be in a hard week.
The general version of this argument, decide what the site has to do before you redesign it, is here. This page is about the part that's particular to nonprofits.
What I think
Most nonprofit sites describe programs while the visitor is deciding something about her own life.
The donor is deciding whether to trust you with money she worked for. The volunteer is deciding whether to give you a Saturday she could spend with her kids. The person who needs the program may be deciding whether to ask for help at all. None of them is reading your site the way the staff reads it, as a record of what the organization does. They're reading it for one answer, and they leave when they don't find it.
That's why "it looks dated" is rarely the real problem, even when it's true. A dated site that answers each visitor's question in one click does more than a beautiful one that makes all three dig.
Design is the last decision, not the first.
Three visitors, one homepage
Each visitor needs something different first, and the homepage can only lead with one.
Someone who might give wants to know what you do, who it's for and whether her money will matter. She wants proof she can check and a donate page that works on a phone in under a minute.
Someone who might need the program wants to know whether it's for him, what it costs if anything and how to start. He may be anxious, short on time or reading on a cracked phone. He doesn't want your history. He wants the next step, in his words.
Someone who might help is a mix. A volunteer wants to know what she'd do and when. A partner wants to know whether you're a serious organization to work with. A funder or program officer wants who you serve, what you measure, who leads and how to reach development.
So pick. If most of your revenue comes from individual giving, the homepage probably leads with the giver, and the other two get a clear door at the top. If the program is the whole point of the site and funding comes mostly from grants, it may lead with the person who needs help, with a calm path for funders who check you before a meeting. Either is defensible. Leading with all three at once isn't a choice. It's a homepage nobody owns.
Choose the one visitor the homepage is for, and give the other two a door they can find in one click.
What a nonprofit website should include
If you're asking what should a nonprofit website include, here's the list I'd start from. It isn't a template. It's what each of the three visitors will look for before they act.
- One sentence at the top that says who the work is for and what changes for them. Not the mission statement, unless the mission statement already does that.
- Three clear doors: give, get help and get involved. Same words in the menu, on the homepage and in the footer.
- A donate page that stands on its own. It says what a gift does, it works on a phone, it offers monthly giving and it doesn't ask for more information than it needs.
- Program pages written for the person who needs them. Who it's for, what happens, what it costs and how to start, in plain words, with a real way to reach a person.
- A path for volunteers and partners that says what happens after they fill in the form, and who will reply.
- A page for funders, even a short one. Who you serve, what you measure, who leads, your most recent annual report or financials and how to reach the development director.
- Proof in the form of what changed, not just what you did. Say where every number came from.
- An email sign-up that says what they'll get, and how often.
- Pages your staff can update without a developer or a former volunteer who still has the login.
- Three numbers you'll watch, one for each visitor. Gifts started and finished, program inquiries and volunteer or partner sign-ups. Not total visits on their own.
People also search for nonprofit website examples and the best nonprofit website design, hoping to borrow one. I'd look at sites you admire with one question in mind: which visitor is this homepage for? The good ones answer it in about five seconds. That's the part worth copying. The look will follow from it.
A site that does those ten things will usually do more for you than a site that looks better and does three.
The donate button nobody decided on
This is a read from a conversation, not a client story, and the organization stays anonymous.
An executive director was walking me through how her organization asks for money. It happened at set moments in the year: Giving Tuesday, the end of the calendar year, the end of the fiscal year and around events. When the conversation turned to the website, she said she wasn't sure how much she cared about website visits. But she did have a donate button.
That's a reasonable way to run a small development calendar. The asks are where the money comes from, and she was right to put her time there.
What it told me was that the site was doing a job nobody had written down. Between those set moments, the website is where people check you. The person who met a board member at an event and looks you up three weeks later meets the site, not the appeal. So does the program officer reading your proposal and the volunteer a friend mentioned. If the site's only decided job is to hold a donate button, it isn't doing anything for any of them.
The fix wasn't a redesign. It was a sentence: between asks, this is what the site is for, and this is how we'll know it's working. Once that's written down, the donate button has company. A page for funders, a door for volunteers and a reason to come back before the next appeal.
The donate button isn't the problem. The problem is that it's the only thing anyone decided.
When the site really is the problem
Sometimes the honest answer is that the site has to go.
It's the right call when the staff can't update it, when it breaks on a phone, when the donation platform loses gifts halfway through, when people can't find you by searching for what you do or when it fails basic accessibility for the people your programs serve. Those are real problems with real costs, and no decision written on a page will fix them.
Even then, decide first. Write down which visitor the homepage is for, what each one should do in one click and the three numbers you'll watch. That page becomes the brief for whoever builds it, and it's how you'll judge whether the new site is better than the old one, rather than just newer.
If the site is broken, rebuild it. Just don't let the rebuild make the decision for you.
Want an outside read on your organization? The Read is one week and $1K, and it ends with one written recommendation. How it works for nonprofits
Read next: Nonprofit marketing strategy: find the one thing in the way first · Website redesign: decide what it has to do first · Marketing and communications for nonprofits