Nonprofit marketing strategy: find the one thing in the way first

A nonprofit marketing strategy is a decision about which of four things is in the way: story, reach, conversion or system. Here's how to find yours.

TL;DR

A nonprofit marketing strategy isn't a list of channels. It's a decision about which one of four things is in the way: the story, who it reaches, what happens when someone is interested or whether the team can keep it running.

In my experience most organizations fix the wrong one first, usually the one they can see. A new website gets built for a story problem. More posts go out for a problem that starts after someone clicks.

So start with what you want people to do. Find which of the four stops them, and spend there, on work your staff can keep running after the launch.

Sometimes the answer really is more output. That's when the people who already hear from you tend to give, volunteer or call. If they don't, more of them won't help.

Related: Marketing and communications for nonprofits · Why isn't my marketing working? · Capital campaigns and the case for support

The short answer

A nonprofit marketing strategy is a decision about which one of four things is in the way: the story, who it reaches, what happens when someone is interested or whether the team can keep it running. Most organizations I talk to fix the wrong one first. Decide what you want people to do, find which of the four stops them and spend there.

Everything else people call nonprofit marketing strategies (the newsletter calendar, the social plan, the gala video, the annual report) is a tactic. Tactics work when they're aimed at the thing in the way. Aimed anywhere else, they're effort the organization can't spare this year.

What I think

It's hard to read the label from inside the bottle.

The people closest to the work know it best. That's exactly why they can't see what someone outside sees: a donor skimming the homepage on a phone, a program officer reading the first page of a proposal, a volunteer choosing between you and three other places for a Saturday morning.

The story is usually already good. Good work does not automatically make a good case for itself, though. The hard part is getting people outside the building to see it, and that's a different job from doing the work well.

It's also why the problem is so easy to misread. A reach problem can look like a website problem. A story problem can look like a fundraising problem. Both feel like "we need more marketing" from the inside, and the board will usually ask for whichever fix it can picture.

Name the problem before you pay for the fix.

Why this year is different

There's less room to guess this year.

The Center for Effective Philanthropy's State of Nonprofits 2026 surveyed 380 nonprofit CEOs in February 2026. In that survey, 39% ran a deficit in fiscal 2025, up from 22% in 2022. 57% say foundation grants are harder to secure. 45% name staffing as their biggest challenge.

On the individual side, the Fundraising Effectiveness Project's Q1 2026 report found that 61% of revenue comes from retained donors. Dollars are up. The number of donors is down.

I can't point you to a study showing that clearer communications brings in more money, and I won't pretend there is one. My read is narrower. When grants are harder, staff are stretched and fewer people are giving more of the total, spending on the wrong one of the four costs more than it used to. The money and the hours aren't there to try something, see it miss and try again.

Story

The meaning isn't making it across.

You'll see it when people outside describe you by your services and nothing else, when five staff members describe the organization five different ways or when a funder who clearly likes the work still can't say why it matters to them. The board asks for "better messaging" and nobody can say what's wrong with the current one.

Rebuilding Together PNW had decades of repair work behind it and a description that carried less than the work did. That was a story problem, so the work was a new framing and a messaging playbook the organization could use after the presentation was over.

If people can't repeat what you do, more reach only spreads the confusion further.

Reach

The right people aren't hearing it.

The signs are familiar. The same faces at every event. A newsletter list that only grows after the gala. Funders whose priorities fit your work almost exactly, who have never heard of you. Most of what an organization sends reaches people who already support it, which is fine for keeping them and useless for finding anyone new.

At Success Academy, where I was on the brand and content team, the job was reaching teachers in the middle of a very public fight. The recruiting work didn't talk around the fight. It told candidates plainly that they'd be joining one.

This is also where more output is sometimes the honest answer. If the people who already hear from you tend to act, and there just aren't enough of them, reach is the problem and more is the fix.

Reach is whether the people who would care ever hear about you at all.

Conversion

They care, but don't act.

This is the one that hides best, because the numbers in front of you look fine. Visits, likes, event attendance and open rates are all there. What's missing is the gift, the sign-up, the second gift or the meeting with the funder who said she was interested.

I don't have a nonprofit case to tell you here, so this is a read. Most conversion problems I see are small and specific. The donate page asks for too much. The email after the event never goes out. The interested funder gets a PDF and then silence. The volunteer form disappears into an inbox nobody checks. None of it is a story problem or a reach problem, and none of it gets fixed by a new campaign.

When people care and don't act, the fix is usually in the step right after they care.

System

Good communications happen, but not reliably.

Everything depends on one person. The newsletter stops when she's on leave. The photos are on someone's phone. The donor list lives in three places that don't agree. With 45% of CEOs in that CEP survey naming staffing as the biggest challenge, this is the one I'd expect more organizations to have this year, whether they call it marketing or not.

SPR isn't a nonprofit. It's a research firm that evaluates programs for governments and foundations. But its lesson carries over: write the work down first. Nobody can tell you which tool to buy until somebody has described how the work actually moves.

And when the help costs more than the organization can pay, the answer can be a different way of doing it. The Story Engine was a 2019 cohort in Utica for four small businesses, not nonprofits, that couldn't afford strategy work. I was its brand strategy coach and facilitator. The client work became the curriculum, so the method stayed in the community after it ended.

A plan the staff can't keep running is a plan for one good quarter.

Start with what you want people to do

Before any of the four, decide what you want people to do. Write it down by audience.

  • A donor: give again, and give before you have to ask twice.
  • A funder: read past the first page, or take the meeting.
  • A volunteer or partner: sign up, and show up a second time.
  • Someone who needs the program: find it, and trust it enough to start.

Then ask, for each one, which of the four stops them. Usually one shows up across most of the list. That's your strategy. It isn't a calendar or a channel mix. It's one sentence about what's in the way and what you'll do about it, with the work sized to what your staff can run every month.

It's also what you take to the board. One decision, with a reason behind it, instead of a wish list. If a campaign is coming, the case for support is usually where the story gets tested first.

This is the work I do with nonprofits. Here's how it works.

Ideas that are really the same mistake

Search for nonprofit marketing ideas and you'll get the same list everywhere: start a podcast, post every day, redo the logo, launch a newsletter, make a video, run a Giving Tuesday push, get on a new platform, redesign the website. Every one of those is a good answer to one of the four and a waste on the other three. A video won't fix a donate page that asks for too much. A new website won't fix a story nobody outside can repeat. A daily posting schedule won't survive the month the one person running it leaves. The ideas aren't wrong. They're answers, and the list never asks the question. The expensive mistake is treating the disguise.

Want an outside read on your organization? The Read is one week and $1K, and it ends with one written recommendation. How it works for nonprofits

Read next: Marketing and communications for nonprofits · Why isn't my marketing working? · Success Academy: the fight was the recruiting pitch


Not sure which problem you’re looking at?

The Quick Read is free and takes three minutes. It tells you whether it’s the look, the message or something else.

Take the Quick Read

Already know? The Outside Read is one week and $1K.